Skip to main content
Ari Berman

Ari Berman

President of Yeshiva University

Nov 10, 2026

7:57
Do you think this will have a ripple effect throughout the South?
8:00
Yes, I believe it's already having a ripple effect in the South.
8:04
You saw Democrats and Black voters fight back against all of these gerrymandering efforts.
8:10
Republicans fell way short of their projected gains because of this.
8:15
They wanted to flip 15 seats, and it looks like they only picked up two or three from the redistricting.
8:20
And of course, there was a lot of other seats that they lost in the process.
8:25
And then they made all these statewide races competitive.
11:29
Talk to us a little bit about what this means in terms of the state politics and the governance that people in those states are going to get now.
25:58
What did you learn there? What did you learn about that? about about why people voted, about how people voted.
26:06
Black voters were extremely upset about the attempt to get rid of black representation.
26:12
They saw this as a continuation of the civil rights struggle of the 1960s.
26:18
I went down to Alabama and I covered Shamari Figures race.
26:20
This was a district that was specifically gerrymandered.
26:23
to get rid of the second black member of Congress from Alabama.
26:27
He ended up winning by eight points in a Trump plus 14 district, which nobody saw coming.
29:12
What happens here? There's a lot
24:40
Are you seeing a wave of this across the country, that the gerrymandering is backfiring on the Republicans?
24:47
It looks likely.
24:48
And Florida is the closest sign of it yet, because like I said, they took four districts and they made them more Republican.
24:56
They were very open about it.
24:57
They said, we redrew these districts to give Republicans four new seats.
25:02
And guess what? They didn't get any of the seats.
25:04
They lost all four of those districts.

1 HR 3 MINS LATER

88:35
and I think a healthy debate about the leadership of the Democratic Party
17:51
So I'm
17:52
curious, how did the DSA candidates do? Some of them did well and some of them might have done better with more support.
17:58
I'm thinking of Angie Nixon in Florida.
18:01
That race was surprisingly competitive.
18:03
She didn't lose by all that much and she got very little support.
18:07
from the National Party.
18:08
They basically, she won the primary, the power brokers in the Democratic Party weren't happy about it, and they basically left her to fend for herself and claimed she wasn't electable because she was a black woman and she was a socialist and this was Florida, the anti-communist state.
19:22
So what do you think that means for the future? Do you think that the Democratic Party is going to look at these results and make moves that shift their
13:19
Well, what about Congress not certifying the results of some contested elections or some closely watched elections, maybe in the Alaska Senate race, for example?
13:30
Yeah, that seems pretty unlikely absent in extraordinary circumstance.
13:33
And one could argue that the Alaska Senate race could get there, particularly if it's the race that decides control of the Senate.
13:39
But so much of this depends on how close the election is.
13:42
If there's a big blue wave and it's very clear Democrats have won both the House and the Senate handily, there's not going to be some kind of massive interference in the vote counting and the election certification process because it'll be so clear that Republicans lost.
13:56
But it's If it's very close and if the Senate race is, for example, the Senate is down to one race and it's a race in which they've already tried to open an inquiry.
14:07
And in Alaska, they've opened what they now call a criminal inquiry.
14:26
are there any other places that you're looking at post-election
59:42
Talk about what you saw in Alabama.
59:44
So it was really interesting.
59:45
Alabama was one of three states that redrew their districts after the Calais decision.
59:50
And I think Alabama was the most egregious because what the Supreme Court said in Calais was you have to show evidence of intentional discrimination in voting, basically smoking gun evidence to be able to strike down a district that dilutes the black vote.
60:04
Well, a federal court in Alabama with two Trump appointees looked at the evidence before Calais and then after Calais and found it was intentional discrimination.
60:13
evidence of discrimination.
60:15
I mean, they literally did exactly what the Supreme Court said you had to do in LA.

9 MINS LATER

69:29
And in Alaska, they're saying we get to decide who's allowed to win.
26:11
I know it differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, Ari, but what can folks do if they are just anxious that someone is going to be at their polling place doing intimidating things?
26:23
So that is actually a scenario that I'm less concerned about.
26:26
And I don't want to say I'm not concerned about it at all, but millions of people have already voted early.
26:31
And we haven't seen any evidence of that kind of thing happening.
26:34
So don't you think they would have done it, for example, when Black voter turnout was surging in Georgia or in Louisiana or in North Carolina or all these places where there's pivotal races? I mean, the fact that it didn't happen there leads me to believe that it probably isn't going to happen.
26:49
And if it does happen on Election Day, more Republicans are going to be likely to be voting on Election Day.
26:54
So if there's any kind of drama at the polls, we don't know that it's necessarily going to affect Democrats more than Republicans.

15 MINS LATER

41:44
You just have to vote harder.
26:11
I know it differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, Ari, but what can folks do if they are just anxious that someone is going to be at their polling place doing intimidating things?
26:23
So that is actually a scenario that I'm less concerned about.
26:26
And I don't want to say I'm not concerned about it at all, but millions of people have already voted early.
26:31
And we haven't seen any evidence of that kind of thing happening.
26:34
So don't you think they would have done it, for example, when Black voter turnout was surging in Georgia or in Louisiana or in North Carolina or all these places where there's pivotal races? I mean, the fact that it didn't happen there leads me to believe that it probably isn't going to happen.
26:49
And if it does happen on Election Day, more Republicans are going to be likely to be voting on Election Day.
26:54
So if there's any kind of drama at the polls, we don't know that it's necessarily going to affect Democrats more than Republicans.

15 MINS LATER

41:44
You just have to vote harder.
26:11
I know it differs from jurisdiction to jurisdiction, Ari, but what can folks do if they are just anxious that someone is going to be at their polling place doing intimidating things?
26:23
So that is actually a scenario that I'm less concerned about.
26:26
And I don't want to say I'm not concerned about it at all, but millions of people have already voted early.
26:31
And we haven't seen any evidence of that kind of thing happening.
26:34
So don't you think they would have done it, for example, when Black voter turnout was surging in Georgia or in Louisiana or in North Carolina or all these places where there's pivotal races? I mean, the fact that it didn't happen there leads me to believe that it probably isn't going to happen.
26:49
And if it does happen on Election Day, more Republicans are going to be likely to be voting on Election Day.
26:54
So if there's any kind of drama at the polls, we don't know that it's necessarily going to affect Democrats more than Republicans.

15 MINS LATER

41:44
You just have to vote harder.
47:57
So how do they parse that out as to like when it's a racial gerrymander in that instance or that that is not insufficient? I mean, were they black people from different parts of the state and, you know, drawing these little squiggle lines or was it basically certain areas that were contiguous?
48:17
Well, that is sort of what the court is grappling with then.
48:21
And the shape of these districts becomes something that they're very much preoccupied by.
48:26
And in some cases, you can draw a very compact district for black representation.
48:31
In some cases, you can't.
48:32
And so the districts look different.
48:34
Right.

5 MINS LATER

53:50
So I think it probably is optics, which is, Not what you want to say about the Supreme Court, but I mean, they're humans and and they're political.
27:42
Like they're specifically trying to poison the well.
27:45
Yeah.
27:45
And I mean, there's another quote.
27:47
I just want to pull up the exact language because my colleague and I, Abby Vassoulis, published a very extensive article about these efforts that PILF is doing.
27:56
It's called Your Private Data is Building Trump's Voter Purge Machine.
28:00
We published it in December of 2025, and it was about all the disinformation and misinformation that was spread by PILF.
28:08
Okay, can I just read this for you? Please.
31:44
Like, can you talk to me a little bit about that? Like, what exactly is Trump trying to do and what's been the pushback?
5:15
[laughs]
5:15
She should still be [laughs] she should ...
5:16
The, the number one rule of, uh, Zooms, unmute your mic.
5:20
Uh, but she should still be in jail.
5:22
I mean, it's, it's amazing that she's even at the White House because she committed actual election fraud.
5:29
She let election deniers access sensitive voting equipment and betrayed the number one rule of an election administrator, which is to protect the vote and to protect people's privacy in a secret ballot.
5:45
And so the fact that she is now out of jail and spinning these far-flung conspiracies is very disturbing.
7:42
[laughs] Um, they've looked, and Bill Barr called it bullshit, and John Solomon said, again, I wanna quote these folks accurately, "All I can acknowledge is what the intelligence shows, right? I only know the intelligence community has zero evidence that someone has flipped, that a foreign power flipped a vote in 2020, 2022, or 2024."
12:12
And Ari, to build on that, I'm wondering if you could describe the relationship between political parties and race, and why trying to separate them may not be realistic.
12:22
Well, that was really the logic that was used by the Roberts Court, that basically they said that if legislatures are drawing districts based on party, that if it has the effect of disenfranchising people based on race, that's just part of a political process.
12:42
That's just a political outcome.
12:44
Now, the problem in a place like Louisiana or Alabama is that voting is incredibly racially polarized, meaning that most white people vote for Republicans and most Black people vote for Democrats, and it's been that way for a long time, and there's a lot more racially polarized voting in the South than there is in a place like California.
13:06
And so if you target people based on party, which is what they claim to be doing, you are essentially targeting them based on race as well.
13:17
And what the Roberts Court has done is they've already said, and this was a very important decision in 2019, the Rucho case, they already said, "We are not going to stop partisan gerrymandering." So that's what allowed all this crazy redistricting to happen in the first place.
13:31
And now they've layered onto that, "Okay, we're also not going to stop racial gerrymandering either, as long as you can say that it's done for political reasons." So now what's going to happen is I believe every state in the South in the next few years is going to redraw their maps to eliminate as many majority-minority districts as possible.

24 MINS LATER

37:54
[laughs]
Lady LuckADVERTISER
34:29
This season, join the rebellion at LuckyRebelClub.com.
34:35
Well, we've talked about some of these laws already, but just the fact that they passed the worst anti-choice law in the country.
34:43
They passed one of the most extreme gun laws in the country that you don't need to have any license or training to carry a gun, which is just totally insane in a state that has a 3500 or more gun deaths a year.
34:58
They have restricted how education can be taught.
35:02
I mean, it was just one thing after another in terms of what the state legislature did.
35:06
And then they added all of this voter suppression on top of it.
35:10
And that's really the thing that they're doing.

8 MINS LATER

43:30
Because my opinion, it's destroying our political system.
20:49
Do you want to explain what's happened there and like how what you think of this?
20:52
Yeah, I mean, it's so convoluted because basically the way it should have worked originally was that Missouri passed a new map to eliminate one of the Democratic seats held by a Black representative, Emanuel Cleaver, from Kansas City.
21:09
And then opponents gathered signatures to force a referendum.
21:13
And that should have blocked the map while the referendum was considered.
21:17
The problem was, is that a number of courts allowed the Republicans to block the maps until the 11th hour, where the Missouri Supreme Court stepped in and said, no, you can't.
21:31
block the map while the referendum is considered.
21:34
But the Missouri Supreme Court, while it made the right decision, could have stepped in months earlier and told the state this.

13 MINS LATER

34:59
You know what I mean? Do you have any hints about what that would look like?
20:42
Do you want to explain what's happened there and like how what you think of this?
20:45
Yeah, I mean, it's so convoluted because basically the way it should have worked originally was that Missouri passed a new map to eliminate one of the Democratic seats held by a Black representative, Emanuel Cleaver, from Kansas City.
21:02
And then opponents gathered signatures to force a referendum.
21:06
And that should have blocked the map while the referendum was considered.
21:10
The problem was, is that a number of courts allowed the Republicans to block the maps until the 11th hour, where the Missouri Supreme Court stepped in and said, no, you can't.
21:25
block the map while the referendum is considered.
21:27
But the Missouri Supreme Court, while it made the right decision, could have stepped in months earlier Like before the primary.

13 MINS LATER

34:27
You know what I mean? Do you have any hints about what that would look like?
15:22
Do you want to explain what's happened there and like how what you think of this?
15:25
Yeah, I mean, it's so convoluted because basically the way it should have worked originally was that Missouri passed a new map to eliminate one of the Democratic seats held by a Black representative, Emanuel Cleaver, from Kansas City.
15:42
And then opponents gathered signatures to force a referendum.
15:46
And that should have blocked the map while the referendum was considered.
15:50
The problem was, is that a number of courts allowed the Republicans to block the maps until the 11th hour, where the Missouri Supreme Court stepped in and said, no, you can't.
16:04
block the map while the referendum is considered.
16:07
But the Missouri Supreme Court, while it made the right decision, could have stepped in months earlier Like before the primary.

10 MINS LATER

26:21
You know what I mean? Do you have any hints about what that would look like?
77:08
So, but my question is, how on earth Could the Supreme Court find justification for any of this when anyone who's read even two pages of the Constitution knows that states control election, not the Department of Homeland Security, not the White House?
77:28
Well, they did a very good sleight of hand, Joy, because what they basically said is we're not ruling on the merits of any of this.
77:38
It's too soon to rule on the merits.
77:40
Therefore, we're just going to let this play out.
77:42
And when it comes back to us, then we'll rule on the merits.
77:45
The problem with that is that, A, it was very obvious that what the Trump administration was doing was unconstitutional.
77:52
But B, the Supreme Court unleashed the very type of chaos that it tells courts not to unleash by changing the rules of an election right before an election.

5 MINS LATER

83:23
But if they're voluntary, then how could the Postal Service refuse to deliver an absentee ballot to a state that didn't create such a list?
37:12
So if you could just talk about that, you know, what is at stake in this and and what does Trump think he'll achieve if this executive order is put in place? Who will be excluded?
37:28
Well, you're right, Nermeen.
37:29
There's been no evidence shown that mail ballots leads to widespread voter fraud.
37:35
Every study has found the opposite, that mail voting is safe and secure.
37:39
So everything that Trump has said about mail voting has been a lie.
37:43
And the fact that Trump himself continues to vote by mail shows that he actually doesn't believe what he's saying about mail voting.
37:51
He clearly wants to do this to hurt the Democratic Party.
42:46
I mean, if you could elaborate on the implications of that and also explain, has the DHS played a role in elections before in American—recent American history?
37:12
So if you could just talk about that, you know, what is at stake in this and and what does Trump think he'll achieve if this executive order is put in place? Who will be excluded?
37:28
Well, you're right, Nermeen.
37:29
There's been no evidence shown that mail ballots leads to widespread voter fraud.
37:35
Every study has found the opposite, that mail voting is safe and secure.
37:39
So everything that Trump has said about mail voting has been a lie.
37:43
And the fact that Trump himself continues to vote by mail shows that he actually doesn't believe what he's saying about mail voting.
37:51
He clearly wants to do this to hurt the Democratic Party.
42:46
I mean, if you could elaborate on the implications of that and also explain, has the DHS played a role in elections before in American—recent American history?
37:15
You know, what is at stake i- i- in this, and, and what does Trump think he'll achieve, uh, if this executive order is put in place? Who will be excluded?
37:28
Well, you're right, Nermeen.
37:29
There's been no evidence shown that mail ballots leads to widespread voter fraud.
37:35
Every study has found the opposite, that mail voting is safe and secure.
37:39
So everything that Trump has said about mail voting has been a lie, and the fact that Trump himself continues to vote by mail shows that he actually [laughs] doesn't believe what he's saying about, uh, mail voting.
37:51
He clearly wants to do this to hurt the Democratic Party.
37:54
Uh, he believes that Democrats vote by mail in larger numbers than Republicans.
42:46
I mean, if you could elaborate on the implications of that, and also explain, has the DHS played a role in elections- Before in American, recent American history?
37:15
You know, what is at stake i- i- in this? And, and what does Trump think he'll achieve, uh, if this executive order is put in place? Who will be excluded?
37:28
Well, you're right, Normeen.
37:29
There's been no evidence shown that mail ballots leads to widespread voter fraud.
37:35
Every study has found the opposite, that mail voting is safe and secure.
37:39
So everything that Trump has said about mail voting has been a lie, and the fact that Trump himself continues to vote by mail shows that he actually [laughs] doesn't believe what he's saying about, uh, mail voting.
37:51
He clearly wants to do this to hurt the Democratic Party.
37:54
Uh, he believes that Democrats vote by mail in larger numbers than Republicans.
42:46
I mean, if you could elaborate on the implications of that, and also explain, has the DHS played a role in elections before in American, recent American history?
9:37
Are you similarly anxious?
9:41
Of course.
9:41
It's impossible, Alicia, not to be anxious given what's going on right now.
9:47
The Fulton County raid made clear that interference in the midterms is not theoretical.
9:51
It is happening.
9:53
They talked for six years about getting those ballots, and then one day they showed up and they took them, and they still have not returned them.
10:00
And the warrant in which they got the ballots was basically just a bunch of recycled BS from election deniers that then had the imprimatur of the federal government, and it was very disturbing to see a judge sign off on that warrant.

5 MINS LATER

15:32
It was also Republican election administrators who were saying, "This is not how this is all supposed to work." It is telling that the administration is not listening to them either.
62:27
What what is in the SAVE Act and where does it stand? It doesn't seem like I mean, yeah, just just give me the breakdown of that.
62:34
I mean, that's a pretty depressing dying wish.
62:37
Like, I hope, like, when I'm dying, I have something better, you know, like something more inspirational to say to my children or something.
62:43
Like, other than pass a terrible pill that has no chance of passing.
62:49
Yes.
62:50
Yeah, I mean, I think it's pretty clear now it's not going to pass.
62:54
They theoretically need 60 votes to pass it.

9 MINS LATER

71:48
And how is that how is that shaping up for this midterms?
49:40
Now, my question, though, is what happens if that in and of itself is not even enough for them? Do they have plans that go further, where they can actually throw out the results of a popular election, or just simply refuse its certification? Because basically, what I'm asking you is, is there a plan where if there's a Trump-like situation in the future, that they can actually put this person in office if they so choose?
50:07
Yeah.
50:07
That, that's their fallback plan.
50:09
That's their ultimate end goal.
50:11
All of these efforts to make it harder to vote don't work.
50:14
They're just gonna try to throw out votes altogether.
50:17
That's their fallback plan.

21 MINS LATER

70:56
And finally, do you foresee a time when they do change their minds and ultimately come back to reality?

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.