Skip to main content

Amy Eisenstein

CEO and co-founder of Capital Campaign Pro, fundraising consultant (ACFRE), and co-host of the All About Capital Campaigns podcast.

Nov 3, 2026

KathleenHOST
10:55
Now, why is securing at least 75% of a campaign goal during the quiet phase is so vital? And how can campaign leaders shift donor conversations from standard pitches to really meaningful collaborative dialogues?
11:11
I think there's a couple of questions in there, so maybe I'll tackle part of it and then let Sarah tackle the rest in part.
11:20
Quiet phase, which is where you raise questions.
11:23
The majority of the campaign funds, 75, 85, or sometimes even 90% of the dollars for a campaign.
11:32
Really the most crucial piece of the active fundraising.
11:38
And if you mentioned Kathleen, it's not about sort of pitching or certainly not standard pitching.
11:47
It is about building relationships with people who have the potential and the inclination to make transformational gifts to your organization.

14 MINS LATER

26:11
Amy, how do you think about these plateaus and campaigns?
6:25
Like, do you have a phase in a capital campaign where this book is particularly helpful? Like, okay, if you're just thinking about having a campaign one day, or what about if folks are in the middle of a campaign, but maybe they're struggling with board member engagement? Like, when should people pick this up?
6:42
Well, I think a year before you start really diving into a campaign.
6:50
You want to prepare your board members long in advance of actually starting to ask for money, and you should be in the plan- an active planning phase for months or maybe a year or longer before you actually start asking for money.
7:06
So, I mean, we hope that you would buy every board member a copy of the book, and one of the ways that we think it should be used is at every board meeting, focus on one chapter or one question.
7:19
And the chapters are short.
7:20
They're only three or four or five pages long, but pick a topic or a question and discuss it at every meeting and of course through the campaign.
7:30
You're right, Mallory.

8 MINS LATER

15:44
Like, talk to me about why that feels so important in terms of changing how capital campaigns are planned for and run, especially in this day and age.
14:01
What if you got 50% through and just got stuck? What would be a next step, or how, w- what happens if you don't hit your goal? What, how would someone work through that?
14:12
Well, I would say take preventative measures to ensure that that doesn't happen in the first place, and that would be working with expertise.
14:23
You know, capital campaign consultants, good experienced ones, have done this dozens or hundreds of times, and so they can help you plan to make sure that that doesn't happen and to strategize perhaps when it does.
14:39
And so starting out correctly is always easier than, than helping an organization that comes to us halfway through and they're stuck.
14:48
Then, you know, we can point to lots and lots of things that went wrong potentially along the way.
14:55
You know, often s- I'll give you an example, a board member's super excited to start the fundraising, and they say, "Well, forget the plan.
15:03
Let's just go out and start asking.

19 MINS LATER

33:58
Mm-hmm
11:03
So can you talk us through what are some of the ways that you un-stall the momentum of a capital campaign that is kind of stuck? Yeah.
11:12
Right.
11:13
So I think that most campaigns have ebbs and flows.
11:17
There's periods of time where there's more momentum and then there's slower periods of time.
11:23
And so I think when organizations are working with an experienced campaign consultant, the consultant has a sense of, is this a normal ebb and flow or do we raise the alarms? But there's lots of strategies and tactics to regain momentum, re-energize a campaign when it's in a downturn.
11:45
And just remember, campaigns are long, right? They're usually three to four years, sometimes a little less, sometimes more.
11:53
And so not every month or quarter is going to have the same amount of momentum and energy.

14 MINS LATER

26:06
Is there a situation where something just did not work, went disastrously awry, and then on the other hand, something that like, hey, really worked far better than you thought it would?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.