Skip to main content
Alan Lightman

Alan Lightman

American physicist and writer

Nov 16, 2026

9:38
So that is interesting that you have that perspective as well.
9:43
Well, you mentioned that we, especially in the academic world, that we have created silos, especially in science.
9:54
And there's an irony to that.
9:58
I agree with you.
9:59
The irony is that the creation of silos has been sort of an inevitable result of science becoming more and more specialized.
10:08
And the advancement of science is associated with the increasing specialization of And today, even biologists have trouble talking to physicists.
10:22
So even in the sciences, we're specialized.
15:12
I know you talk a little bit about it, but what do we lose when we maintain it?
14:28
I know you talk a little bit about it, but what do we lose when we maintain it?
14:34
Well, if you go back to the first universities in Europe, I think the University of Bologna was one of the earliest.
14:43
The course of study was called the trivium, and then it became the quadrivium.
14:50
And it It did combine the sciences and the humanities.
14:57
And I think that just as in science itself, the advance of knowledge inevitably created a specialization.
15:08
And I don't know exactly when that specialization occurred.
15:11
It probably would have been in the 1600s, but I'm not an historian.

8 MINS LATER

speaker_4ADVERTISER
23:26
Shop Jared Jewelers.
8:39
So that is interesting that you have that perspective as well.
8:44
Well, you mentioned that we, especially in the academic world, that we have created silos, especially in science.
8:55
And there's an irony to that.
8:58
I agree with you.
8:59
The irony is that the creation of silos has been sort of an inevitable result of science becoming more and more specialized.
9:09
And the advancement of science is associated with the increasing specialization of And today, even biologists have trouble talking to physicists.
9:23
So even in the sciences, we're specialized.
14:12
I know you talk a little bit about it, but what do we lose when we maintain it?
7:39
So that is interesting that you have that perspective as well.
7:43
Well, you mentioned that we, especially in the academic world, that we have created silos, especially in science.
7:55
And there's an irony to that.
7:58
I agree with you.
7:59
The irony is that the creation of silos has been sort of an inevitable result of science becoming more and more specialized.
8:09
And the advancement of science is associated with the increasing specialization of And today, even biologists have trouble talking to physicists.
8:23
So even in the sciences, we're specialized.
13:12
I know you talk a little bit about it, but what do we lose when we maintain it?
17:58
And I, I asked him, "Well, what do you think about Brian's, uh, argument?"
18:02
Well, I, I don't think that he's wrong, but I think that the problem is philosophically...... more disturbing than what he is confessing.
18:13
He said, "Well, I, I think it's gonna be much harder than Brian thinks to actually sense or encounter or measure these other universes, if, if they exist at all."
18:22
We don't even know whether the other universes exist in the same space and time that we do.
18:28
And there are other physicists who feel that these universes are, e- even in principle never, never observable by us, that we will never be able to have any physical evidence of their existence.
18:44
And that possibility is what I find disturbing.
18:52
It may be that this is the way nature is.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.