Listener sentiment
Listeners remain overwhelmingly positive about "You're Dead to Me," with Greg Jenner widely praised as a warm, knowledgeable host and the show's three-way format — host, expert historian, and comedian — still regarded as its signature strength. The most persistent point of friction in recent weeks is comedian selection: a growing chorus of reviewers feel certain guest comedians over-talk the experts, fail to land jokes, or bring a perceived political agenda that disrupts the educational flow, with the Francis Galton episode and several American comedians singled out repeatedly. At the same time, other listeners praise the very same guests, illustrating how subjective the chemistry is from episode to episode. The Dead Funny History children's spin-off continues to divide the audience — parents and younger listeners champion it, while many adult subscribers want it moved to a separate feed — and radio edits draw a similar mixed reaction. Underlying these format and curation debates, the core show's quality is rarely questioned; listeners consistently describe it as informative, funny, and accessible, and repeatedly request broader geographic coverage and a return to longer, uncut episodes.
Apple4.5 · 1,161
Summary generated Sep 18, 2026
