Sep 25, 2026 · 35 min · 9 segments
Home insurance may seem like a chore to deal with, but it’s an essential protection. So, why are so many homeowners having their claims rejected? In this episode, Which? insurance expert Dean Sobers…
Dean SobersGuest
James RoweHost
So depending on the type of product that you have, so whether it's a combined buildings and contents policy or a contents-only policy or a buildings policy, the decline rates range between 38%, sort of the highest, and 29% at the At the lowest.

And for the majority of people, it's sort of 29% because that's the combined policies, which most people have.

But just to bring another stat to the attention as well, because I guess if a claim is declined, the next step for a lot of people is to go to the FOS, the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Yeah, so as you mentioned, if you have any kind of dispute, so it doesn't have to be that your claim's declined, but if you're unhappy with how the insurer's treated you, you make a complaint with them.

And then if you're unhappy with how that complaint winds up, then the next step is to go to the FOS.

The FOS, Financial Ombudsman Service, they receive and deal with thousands of complaints every year.

So what we thought we would do this time is we sent them a freedom of information request to find out what types of complaints they were dealing with in the home insurance space.

So the top three kinds of complaints were, the top one, this probably isn't going to be hugely surprising, is ones about declined claims.

So these kind of varied in terms of how they ranked, depending on whether they were buildings claims or content claims.

But then what we also were kind of interested in was how often they would side with the customer in resolving the complaint.

And they were most likely to uphold the complaint when it came to one that was about a delay.

So depending on the type of product that you have, so whether it's a combined buildings and contents policy or a contents-only policy or a buildings policy, the decline rates range between 38%, sort of the highest, and 29% at the At the lowest.

And for the majority of people, it's sort of 29% because that's the combined policies, which most people have.

But just to bring another stat to the attention as well, because I guess if a claim is declined, the next step for a lot of people is to go to the FOS, the Financial Ombudsman Service.

Yeah, so as you mentioned, if you have any kind of dispute, so it doesn't have to be that your claim's declined, but if you're unhappy with how the insurer's treated you, you make a complaint with them.

And then if you're unhappy with how that complaint winds up, then the next step is to go to the FOS.

The FOS, Financial Ombudsman Service, they receive and deal with thousands of complaints every year.

So what we thought we would do this time is we sent them a freedom of information request to find out what types of complaints they were dealing with in the home insurance space.

So the top three kinds of complaints were, the top one, this probably isn't going to be hugely surprising, is ones about declined claims.

So these kind of varied in terms of how they ranked, depending on whether they were buildings claims or content claims.

But then what we also were kind of interested in was how often they would side with the customer in resolving the complaint.

And they were most likely to uphold the complaint when it came to one that was about a delay.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.