Listener sentiment
Listeners have long praised "When It Hits the Fan" for its expert, insider perspective on PR crises and media narratives, with the hosts' decades of frontline communications experience lending genuine credibility. However, the podcast has experienced a significant and acute decline in recent months following the unannounced departure of co-host Simon Lewis. The transition to new co-hosts—most notably Farzana Baduel—has disappointed many loyal listeners, who report that while her knowledge is substantial, her delivery comes across as stiff and scripted, lacking the natural rapport and conversational flow of the original pairing. Reviewers consistently cite the show feeling like only "half of what it was" without Lewis, and several have unsubscribed or indicated they may leave. A minority of listeners appreciate the fresh perspectives, but the recurring concern about rebuilding chemistry and on-air comfort suggests the hosts will need time and opportunity to find their rhythm, or risk losing the core audience that made the show a weekly must-listen.
Apple3.6 · 43
Summary generated May 29, 2026
