Listener sentiment
True Crime All The Time continues to command a deeply loyal audience who prize hosts Mike Ferguson and Mike Gibson's chemistry, thorough case research, and the balance of serious storytelling with lighthearted banter. Long-time listeners describe the two Mikes as friends they look forward to each week, praising the detail given to both well-known and lesser-known cases and the respect shown toward victims while appreciating the humor as necessary levity in heavy subject matter. The show remains starkly polarized over the same recurring frictions, though: a vocal minority finds the banter excessive, childish, and distracting, with some accusing the hosts of misogynistic humor and jokes that cross the line of respect toward victims — particularly in coverage of stalking and domestic violence cases. A smaller set of critics also flags factual inaccuracies in specific episodes, uneven audio levels between the two hosts, unwanted political commentary, and heavy ad loads. The core divide is unchanged from the prior window: listeners who connect with the hosts' dynamic tend to be fiercely devoted, while those who prefer a tighter, more case-focused narrative without frequent tangents or sensitive-humor concerns tend to drop off quickly.
Apple4.3 · 1,137
Summary generated Jul 12, 2026
