Listener sentiment
Listeners overwhelmingly regard The X-Cast as the premier X-Files rewatch podcast, praising host Tony Black's deep knowledge, affable style, and the rotating panel of co-hosts and guests who bring fresh perspectives to each episode. Reviewers consistently highlight the episode-by-episode analysis, behind-the-scenes interviews, and the show's coverage of extended-universe media as standout features. The most persistent criticism — raised independently by several reviewers across years — is the podcast's casual handling of spoilers, which frustrates first-time viewers trying to follow along as they watch the series. A secondary, recurring concern is inconsistent quality tied to the rotating host format: some guests lack the charisma or focus of the regular panel, and a few episodes drift far from the episode under discussion. One recent reviewer also voiced frustration with a specific co-host's political tangents and verbose style. Despite these caveats, the overall sentiment remains strongly positive, with listeners describing the show as an essential, well-produced companion for any X-Files fan.
Apple4.5 · 41
Summary generated Jul 9, 2026
