Listener sentiment
The Unforgotten built a devoted following with its first three seasons, and those early installments still draw enthusiastic praise for thorough investigative journalism, empathetic storytelling, and host Carol Dawson's distinctive narration — with Season 3's "Finding Dolores Wulff" remaining a listener favorite, particularly for the widely beloved "Uncle Slick" segments. However, the most recent ratings continue a clear downward drift that began with Seasons 4 and 5. The newest reviews are uniformly critical to mixed, and their complaints have sharpened into a consistent set of themes: a perceived lack of original reporting, with the host accused of leaning too heavily on other podcasts and amateur internet sleuths rather than conducting independent investigation; editorial bias, particularly around the Charles Flores death-row case in Season 5, where listeners feel the hosts frame a convicted murderer too sympathetically; and frustration with tangential content, repetitive structuring, and unnecessary recap or bonus episodes. A few reviewers also bristle at the host's dismissive treatment of psychics and metaphysical elements discussed in certain cases. While the show's core strengths are still acknowledged by long-time listeners, the prevailing sentiment in the current window is disappointment from fans who feel the podcast has moved away from the rigorous, victim-centered reporting that defined its strongest seasons.
Apple4.4 · 128
Summary generated Aug 2, 2026
