Sep 9, 2026 · 25 min · 8 segments
In this episode, I’m looking at the difference between privacy and secrecy online, and why I believe younger children need much more visibility and supervision than we sometimes realise. We’ll…
Now, of course, there are going to be some examples where estranged parents or unsafe adults in a young person's life might need, uh, a different set of rules here.
But that aside, I say this having watched plenty of well-meaning parents get talked out of or ignore this and treat their children as little adults.
So if a child asks for a bit of privacy or sets something up on their own, it sounds kind of reasonable, especially for those capable, independent kids, and the parent might go along with it or not want to appear harsh.
They're gonna do the right thing." But actually, I don't think this has anything to do with trust.
I think that a seven-year-old or even a nine-year-old or maybe possibly an 11-year-old asking for unsupervised online space isn't showing you that they're trustworthy.
Testing those boundaries, testing the edges, which is exactly what kids are supposed to do, right? Exactly what kids are supposed to do.
Your job is to hold the edges for them until they're old enough to hold that themselves.
Now, when we think about capability, I often go back to the most wonderful analogy that was used by Professor Tanya Byron, an absolute legend, um, who wrote a re- some really important reports in the UK back in 2008, 2009, 2010, that kind of time.
And she talked about online life and children a bit like learning to swim, so she suggested that when it comes to swimming, there's no way that we would take a young child with no previous experience of being in the water out into the middle of the ocean and plop them in with the sharks and say, "Have a lovely time, darling.
We teach children to swim in highly controllable environments where we make the water as safe as we can with shallow ends, with buoyancy aids, with one-to-one supervision, with lifeguards and fencing and, and all of that to make sure that the water is safe enough and the risks are managed well enough and the supervision is in place to help that child learn to navigate the risks themselves.
I worry that we still don't perceive necessarily the dangers of online spaces well enough, and there's quite a lot of plopping the kids in with the sharks because the water looks lovely.
So to come back to privacy for a second, privacy and independence go hand in hand, and growing up does need independence, and it does need privacy, whether it's the, the diary or the closed bedroom door or the, the in-joke with the friend that doesn't get repeated at the dinner table.
All of that is healthy, right? It's part of becoming a person that's separated from their parents.
But I think we have to be really careful because the internet or the social media apps or the games are not bedroom doors themselves.
The bedroom door only ever contains what happens in one-- inside one space anyway, and the device, whether it's the games console or the iPad or the phone or whatever, that can put a child in so many different situations, so many different contexts, and mixed in with so many people.
And once something happens in those spaces online, it doesn't stay contained in the way that something physical that happens in a room might.
So what we're untangling today then and exploring together is gonna be about privacy and how we manage that alongside sort of this idea of autonomy and ind- independence for young people, but also where secrecy fits in here.
What it means to be disingenuous, what it means to be devious, and to be able to tell those things apart so that we can understand intent.
Now, for a young child, as I've mentioned at the start here, I don't think there should be room for either of those things.
Now, of course, there are going to be some examples where estranged parents or unsafe adults in a young person's life might need, uh, a different set of rules here.
But that aside, I say this having watched plenty of well-meaning parents get talked out of or ignore this and treat their children as little adults.
So if a child asks for a bit of privacy or sets something up on their own, it sounds kind of reasonable, especially for those capable, independent kids, and the parent might go along with it or not want to appear harsh.
They're gonna do the right thing." But actually, I don't think this has anything to do with trust.
I think that a seven-year-old or even a nine-year-old or maybe possibly an 11-year-old asking for unsupervised online space isn't showing you that they're trustworthy.
Testing those boundaries, testing the edges, which is exactly what kids are supposed to do, right? Exactly what kids are supposed to do.
Your job is to hold the edges for them until they're old enough to hold that themselves.
Now, when we think about capability, I often go back to the most wonderful analogy that was used by Professor Tanya Byron, an absolute legend, um, who wrote a re- some really important reports in the UK back in 2008, 2009, 2010, that kind of time.
And she talked about online life and children a bit like learning to swim, so she suggested that when it comes to swimming, there's no way that we would take a young child with no previous experience of being in the water out into the middle of the ocean and plop them in with the sharks and say, "Have a lovely time, darling.
We teach children to swim in highly controllable environments where we make the water as safe as we can with shallow ends, with buoyancy aids, with one-to-one supervision, with lifeguards and fencing and, and all of that to make sure that the water is safe enough and the risks are managed well enough and the supervision is in place to help that child learn to navigate the risks themselves.
I worry that we still don't perceive necessarily the dangers of online spaces well enough, and there's quite a lot of plopping the kids in with the sharks because the water looks lovely.
So to come back to privacy for a second, privacy and independence go hand in hand, and growing up does need independence, and it does need privacy, whether it's the, the diary or the closed bedroom door or the, the in-joke with the friend that doesn't get repeated at the dinner table.
All of that is healthy, right? It's part of becoming a person that's separated from their parents.
But I think we have to be really careful because the internet or the social media apps or the games are not bedroom doors themselves.
The bedroom door only ever contains what happens in one-- inside one space anyway, and the device, whether it's the games console or the iPad or the phone or whatever, that can put a child in so many different situations, so many different contexts, and mixed in with so many people.
And once something happens in those spaces online, it doesn't stay contained in the way that something physical that happens in a room might.
So what we're untangling today then and exploring together is gonna be about privacy and how we manage that alongside sort of this idea of autonomy and ind- independence for young people, but also where secrecy fits in here.
What it means to be disingenuous, what it means to be devious, and to be able to tell those things apart so that we can understand intent.
Now, for a young child, as I've mentioned at the start here, I don't think there should be room for either of those things.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.