Listener sentiment
The Room remains a polarised listen a month into its run, though the newest reviews have warmed again after the mid-October slump, with devoted fans — many of them new mothers — describing the show as candid, relatable and like eavesdropping on a group of friends, and crediting the three hosts' natural chemistry, intelligence and warmth. The recurring structural complaint persists across both camps: the census-statistics quiz format feels repetitive and hard to follow, and listeners want the hosts to deep-dive topics rather than reel off numbers; several also question whether the network's survey genuinely represents ordinary women or just its own fan base. Other criticisms that have hardened since launch are the show's fixation on weight loss and GLP-1s, a perceived tone-deaf remark ranking a working mother above one on maternity leave, and a sense that the hosts are privileged and unrepresentative of families facing a cost-of-living squeeze. There is also quiet disagreement over scope — some mothers love the focus while women without children feel it's really a parenting podcast despite its broader billing. The overall picture is a promising new show whose likeable hosts are being let down by format choices that early adopters, including loyal network fans, are openly urging the producers to change.
Apple3.8 · 29
Summary generated Nov 2, 2026
