The Page & Podium Podcast with Dr. Amanda Nell Edgar
Oct 6, 2026 · 29 min · 9 segments
Want to know whether AI has a place in your writing process? This is the first episode in a four-part series on AI and nonfiction writing, and we’re starting with the most important question: what…
Amanda Nell EdgarHost[upbeat music] As I mentioned in the teaser to this episode, y'all, I have been on such a deep dive down the rabbit hole of AI.
Now, I mostly feel like this is a professional obligation that I carry as someone who does own a hybrid publishing company.
And of course, as y'all know, I also work with a lot of first-time authors to do a lot of different things with writing, editing, and publishing their books, both within Page and Podium and outside of Page and Podium.
But one thing that I have really noticed as I have been down this kind of rabbit hole and reading different experts' perspectives, is that a lot of the things that I feel really matter to writers are getting dramatically overshadowed by a very black-and-white culture around AI.
I was really more just thinking about when people use these tools, what is the result? Is it actually delivering what folks are hoping it will deliver, or is it taking us off course, or is a little bit of both? Y'all, you know I come from a social science background.
I am always really curious, not only to make kind of a line in the sand, a decision one way or another, but really to dig into what's really happening and really understand it.
I feel like when we put our beliefs out there, we really have an obligation to be able to back them up with a really solid explanation.
And to make a long story long, [laughs] I realized that we weren't really getting this in most of the writing conversations on AI.
I decided that I wanted to share with y'all some of the thoughts that I have been having.
And it's really changed a lot of the way that I think about things, not necessarily in terms of is it good or bad, and they're changing my mind or not changing my mind.
But rather in that I think it's so important that we understand when a lot of people are using a tool, why are they using it? What are they getting out of it? And that's really what I wanna focus on today.
Now, most of these are things that are being talked about all over the Internet, and they're not particularly connected to writing, but some of them are, and that's what I wanna go into today.
So just to kind of give you a sense of where I am personally, because of course my personal perspective is going to leak into this episode and our whole series, I wanted to share with you, I am really worried about a lot of things with AI.
I am very, very worried economically that so much money is being poured into something that has not been particularly transparent in terms of how the economics are working.
And maybe most of all, what I'm really worried about is that there is a technology that could be powerful at some point, and it seems as though most of the folks who really could be intervening to make it an actual social good are kind of just running a little wild with it.
But I also wanna share with you that I am also very, very skeptical about these tools.
A lot of the messages that we're getting are about how AI is going to take over the world, essentially.
[upbeat music] As I mentioned in the teaser to this episode, y'all, I have been on such a deep dive down the rabbit hole of AI.
Now, I mostly feel like this is a professional obligation that I carry as someone who does own a hybrid publishing company.
And of course, as y'all know, I also work with a lot of first-time authors to do a lot of different things with writing, editing, and publishing their books, both within Page and Podium and outside of Page and Podium.
But one thing that I have really noticed as I have been down this kind of rabbit hole and reading different experts' perspectives, is that a lot of the things that I feel really matter to writers are getting dramatically overshadowed by a very black-and-white culture around AI.
I was really more just thinking about when people use these tools, what is the result? Is it actually delivering what folks are hoping it will deliver, or is it taking us off course, or is a little bit of both? Y'all, you know I come from a social science background.
I am always really curious, not only to make kind of a line in the sand, a decision one way or another, but really to dig into what's really happening and really understand it.
I feel like when we put our beliefs out there, we really have an obligation to be able to back them up with a really solid explanation.
And to make a long story long, [laughs] I realized that we weren't really getting this in most of the writing conversations on AI.
I decided that I wanted to share with y'all some of the thoughts that I have been having.
And it's really changed a lot of the way that I think about things, not necessarily in terms of is it good or bad, and they're changing my mind or not changing my mind.
But rather in that I think it's so important that we understand when a lot of people are using a tool, why are they using it? What are they getting out of it? And that's really what I wanna focus on today.
Now, most of these are things that are being talked about all over the Internet, and they're not particularly connected to writing, but some of them are, and that's what I wanna go into today.
So just to kind of give you a sense of where I am personally, because of course my personal perspective is going to leak into this episode and our whole series, I wanted to share with you, I am really worried about a lot of things with AI.
I am very, very worried economically that so much money is being poured into something that has not been particularly transparent in terms of how the economics are working.
And maybe most of all, what I'm really worried about is that there is a technology that could be powerful at some point, and it seems as though most of the folks who really could be intervening to make it an actual social good are kind of just running a little wild with it.
But I also wanna share with you that I am also very, very skeptical about these tools.
A lot of the messages that we're getting are about how AI is going to take over the world, essentially.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.