Listener sentiment
The Megyn Kelly Show's ratings remain sharply polarized, with negative reviews continuing to outweigh positive ones through mid-September. The most recurring complaint, voiced repeatedly by self-described former daily listeners, is that Kelly has moved away from the hard political and legal analysis that built her audience toward repetitive celebrity and pop-culture commentary (Meghan Markle, Blake Lively, Michelle Obama, Oprah) and extended fixation on individual true-crime and legal cases that crowd out pressing national news. A parallel and intensifying criticism centers on Kelly's association with Candace Owens and Tucker Carlson, with multiple reviewers accusing her of lending credibility to conspiracy theories, failing to challenge sympathetic guests, and sacrificing her earlier reputation for evidence-based journalism; several also tie this to a perceived shift in her stance on Israel, accusing her of antisemitism or of bending to pressure from her newer guest circle. Additional criticisms cite escalating profanity, a catty or mean-girl tone, and over-promotion of her husband's book. A loyal contingent continues to champion Kelly's independence, sharp legal analysis, and willingness to cover stories mainstream outlets avoid, and her "MK Confidential" true-crime series — particularly the JonBenet Ramsey and DC sniper installments — draws consistent, enthusiastic praise, though some fans wish it were separated from the main feed so it doesn't crowd out political coverage. The fundamental divide shows no sign of easing: the same programming choices that energize her remaining base are the ones driving long-time listeners away.
Apple3.2 · 1,236
Summary generated Sep 11, 2026
