Listener sentiment
The dominant story across recent reviews is the creators' announcement that The Mario Bros. Show will conclude on October 2nd, which has prompted a flood of emotional farewells from deeply devoted listeners — many of them children and young teens who describe the show as a bedtime ritual, a daily companion, or something that helped them through difficult personal moments. Fans are eagerly anticipating the final "Thousand Year Door Saga" arriving around September 18th, and several report having already replayed all 132 episodes multiple times. Sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive, with listeners praising the humor, the ambitious multi-episode story sagas (the Super Smash Bros. arc is most often singled out as a creative high point), and Paul Robinson's voice work across a large cast of characters, with Toad and Luigi drawing particular affection. The review section also functions as a community forum where listeners pitch crossover episode ideas — Minecraft, Kirby, Batman, Donkey Kong, Disney, and others — alongside a persistent, emoji-tagged campaign to give Daisy a speaking role. The few recurring criticisms are narrow but consistent: one reviewer flagged poor audio quality with audible breathing and mic noise, forced-sounding laughter, and scripts that felt AI-generated; others find the recast Peach voice underwhelming, and there is frustration when Friday releases are skipped in favor of Patreon-exclusive content.
Apple4.8 · 411
Summary generated Sep 20, 2026
