Listener sentiment
The Knife continues to command strong listener loyalty, and the most recent months of feedback are almost uniformly enthusiastic. The dominant theme is praise for hosts Hannah Smith and Patia Eaton's empathetic, victim-centered approach to true crime: reviewers repeatedly single out their respectful handling of sensitive stories, thorough research, natural interviewing, refusal to sensationalize, and the wide variety of cases they cover, with many calling the show a weekly highlight they rush to hear first. Discovery stories recur often — listeners arrived through Hannah's earlier work on The Opportunist, the Exactly Right network, or a recommendation from My Favorite Murder — and several describe episodes on fraud and mental health resonating deeply with their own lives. Criticism is sparse and scattered: a few listeners find the hosts' commentary occasionally naïve or one-sided, one found some episodes hard to follow, and a single reviewer accused the show of mishandling a story involving a sex offender — a charge other listeners publicly rebutted. Compared with earlier feedback, the graver concerns about missing trigger warnings and perceived ideological leanings have faded from the newest reviews, suggesting the earlier criticisms were isolated rather than a growing trend.
Apple4.7 · 202
Summary generated Sep 1, 2026