Jul 7, 2026 · 1 hr 26 min · 15 segments
For nearly two thousand years, Jesus' enemies have made the same astonishing claim. They never denied His miracles. They claimed He performed them through sorcery. In this episode of *The Dancing…
Pastor NellyHostReport suspicious activities and call 911 for immediate response.
The city is swollen with pilgrims.
Priests move through the temple courts like they own eternity.
Rabbis debate the law with polished certainty.
Rome watches from the fortress above, one hand on its sword, the other on its taxes.
Then a man is brought through the crowd.
He can't see.
He can't speak.
To the people around him he is more than disabled.
He is a spiritual problem, a theological category, a case to be explained.
The rabbis had names for men like him, possessed, demonized, a life occupied by hostile territory.
He cannot ask Jesus for mercy because his mouth will not obey him.
He cannot even look into the eyes of the one standing before him because darkness has become his whole world.
He is a locked house, every door bolted shut, and no one believes there's a key.
Then Jesus of Nazareth walks up to the front door.
Matthew doesn't waste words.
He simply writes, Then a demon-oppressed man who was blind and mute was brought to him, and he healed
the man spoke and saw.
Just like that, the impossible becomes ordinary.
Eyes that had never seen suddenly filled with color.
A tongue imprisoned by silence suddenly finds its voice.
The crowd doesn't respond with polite applause.
It erupts.
Whispers become questions.
Questions become declarations.
That isn't just a compliment.
That is a messianic title.
The question hanging over Jerusalem for centuries has just escaped into the public.
Could this actually be Him? Could this be the One? Now stop watching Jesus for a moment.
Watch the religious establishment.
Watch the scholars, the so-called experts.
Watch the men whose entire lives have been devoted to recognizing the Messiah.
Notice what they do not say.
They never claim the man wasn't blind.
They never suggest he learned to speak beforehand.
They never accuse the crowd of hallucinating.
Nor do they investigate whether a miracle actually occurred.
Because denying the miracle had become impossible.
The evidence was standing there, blinking in the sunlight, speaking with his own mouth.
So they reached for another explanation.
When the Pharisees heard it, they said, It is only by Beelzebul, the prince of demons, that this man casts out demons.
Think carefully about what just happened.
That sentence is one of the most remarkable admissions in the entire New Testament.
They have conceded the event.
Their only dispute is its source.
Not he didn't do it, but we know how he did it.
Not divine power, but dark power.
By demonic authority, they accused him of being hell wearing the mask of heaven.
And that raises a question that has echoed through history for nearly 2000 years.
What do you do when reality refuses to cooperate with your theology? When the evidence standing in front of you won't fit the system you've already built? Do you change your theology? Or do you invent a new explanation for the evidence? The men standing in that crowd chose the second option, and their dark explanation refused to die.
It survived the crucifixion.
It survived the resurrection, Pentecost.
It survived the fall of the temple, crossed deserts.
It followed rabbis into exile, into Babylon.
It was abated in academies from Judea to Babylon.
It changed languages.
It absorbed generations of argument.
And centuries later, it was preserved in the single most influential work of rabbinic Judaism, the Talmud.
There the accusation appears again.
Jesus did extraordinary things, but he did them through sorcery.
Not because the miracles could be denied, but because they had to be explained.
Today we're going to examine those claims.
We're going to read the passages for ourselves.
We'll look at the famous ones, the obscure ones, the disputed ones, the passages that survived, the passages that were censored from printed editions, the passages that were burned along with the entire volumes of the Talmud during the religious conflicts of medieval Europe.
We're not interested in caricatures today.
We're not interested in internet memes.
We're interested in history.
In evidence.
were interested in asking why one of the most enduring accusations against Jesus was never that he failed to perform miracles.
It was that he performed them through the wrong power.
For nearly 2,000 years, the central argument about Jesus of Nazareth has rarely been whether something extraordinary happened.
The real battle has always been over one question.
Who authorized it?
Read the full transcript.
Create an account to read the whole episode, search across every transcript, and follow the shows you care about.
