Listener sentiment
The Brilliant Idiots is sharply polarized, with roughly half of recent listeners giving one star while praising supporters highlight the hosts' chemistry and comedic chemistry. The dominant complaint—especially among long-time listeners spanning a decade or more—is a perceived overemphasis on politics and a drift from comedy toward political commentary, notably intensified around the 2024 election cycle. Many former fans accuse Andrew Schulz of adopting an increasingly Trump-friendly stance ("MAGA Andy"), lacking accountability, and diluting the show's once-balanced humor with what some frame as racist or misogynistic material. A secondary but consistent complaint targets Taylor, the on-air producer, whose vocal presence and opinions are widely criticized as grating and immature. Core listeners cite the loss of the show's original entertainment-first identity as the reason for unsubscribing after years of loyalty, while remaining fans appreciate the willingness to tackle controversial topics and the rapport between Charlamagne and Schulz.
Apple3.8 · 674
Summary generated May 29, 2026
