Listener sentiment
The Boo Crew enjoys extraordinarily strong listener sentiment, with the vast majority of recent reviews praising the show as a must-listen for horror fans. Listeners consistently celebrate the hosts' genuine passion for the genre, the chemistry between them, and the caliber of guests—particularly highlighting Trevor's legendary guest introductions. The show is widely credited with introducing audiences to new horror films, music, and overlooked gems, and many reviewers describe listening as like hanging out with knowledgeable, welcoming friends. A small but consistent critical thread criticizes the production as overly polished and the hosts' delivery as theatrical or radio-DJ-like—some describe it as inauthentic "morning zoo" energy that undermines the podcast's credibility with genre purists. A handful of reviews also cite technical issues, including audible editing cuts and an over-long intro. Overall, the show has built a deeply loyal fanbase around its accessible, celebratory take on horror culture, though production choices continue to polarize a vocal minority.
Apple4.8 · 145
Summary generated May 29, 2026