Listener sentiment
Recent listener sentiment for That's Spooky is overwhelmingly positive, with reviewers almost universally enthusiastic about hosts Johnny and Tyler. The most consistent praise centers on the duo's chemistry and banter, which listeners describe as feeling like time spent with close friends, and their careful balance of humor with genuine respect for the subjects and victims they cover. Many reviewers highlight the thorough research and source citation as a standout quality, and the show's unique blend of true crime, paranormal topics, and RuPaul's Drag Race recaps is frequently cited as a draw that sets it apart in a crowded genre. A large share of listeners mention discovering the podcast through Morbid and express deep personal attachment, crediting the show with getting them through difficult periods, commutes, and workdays. The hosts' visibility as a queer couple and their candid discussion of LGBTQ+ topics and mental health is a recurring source of appreciation, particularly among listeners seeking representation and allyship. The handful of critical reviews come from listeners who object to the extensive off-topic banter before stories begin or who feel the queer cultural content overshadows the spooky subject matter — critiques that appear to stem from mismatched expectations rather than production quality concerns.
Apple4.9 · 228
Summary generated Aug 26, 2026
