Listener sentiment
Trekcast was long regarded as one of the best Star Trek podcasts available, with listeners repeatedly praising the chemistry, humor, and deep Trek knowledge of its original hosting team — David, Darren, and Alicia. Reviews from the show's golden era (roughly 2009–2017) describe it as feeling like a lively conversation with knowledgeable friends, blending episode analysis, convention coverage, interviews, and tangential sci-fi culture with a fun, laid-back tone. Sentiment shifted sharply after the original hosts departed and the show was rebooted with a new lineup. The most recent reviews — spanning 2020 to 2026 — are predominantly negative, with former fans lamenting the loss of the original crew's rapport and production quality, and several describing the new iteration as a diminished, unrecognizable version of the show they loved. A handful of critical reviews from both eras also flagged issues with the hosts' treatment of female characters and on-air conduct, though these were isolated complaints against an otherwise enthusiastic listener base. The dominant story across the full review window is one of a beloved podcast whose audience has largely not followed it past the original hosts' exit.
Apple4.3 · 80
Summary generated Aug 26, 2026
