Listener sentiment
Sofia with an F draws a sharply polarized response: a devoted core of listeners praise Sofia's unfiltered authenticity, sharp wit, and the intimate, voice-memo-from-a-best-friend quality of her solo episodes, while a nearly equal contingent of detractors find the show vapid, poorly paced, and stale. The most enthusiastic fans — many of whom followed Sofia after her Call Her Daddy departure — gravitate toward her solo casts and episodes featuring family members, particularly her cousin Alex and her mother, and tend to view celebrity guest interviews as the show's weak spot. Common criticisms center on excessive ad loads (especially on short "mini" episodes), a vocal style many find grating, a perception that Sofia hasn't evolved alongside her maturing audience, and guest choices that feel under-researched or mismatched. Notably, several negative reviews come from self-identified former fans who have gradually drifted away, suggesting the show's core challenge is retaining listeners as they age out of Sofia's early-twenties persona rather than attracting them in the first place.
Apple4.2 · 1,367
Summary generated Aug 19, 2026
