Listener sentiment
Small Town Murder continues to draw overwhelmingly enthusiastic ratings, with the vast majority of recent listeners calling it their favorite podcast and a daily companion for commutes, work shifts, chores, and even falling asleep. James and Jimmie are praised for meticulous research into lesser-known cases, the signature town-demographics opening segments, and a comedic chemistry that lightens dark material while staying respectful to victims. The Netflix series remains the most common entry point for new fans, who frequently report bingeing the entire back catalog, while longtime listeners value the lengthy episodes and twice-weekly schedule. A small but consistent minority raises recurring frustrations: ad load — particularly supplement advertising — draws pointed criticism, a few long-time followers feel one host has grown more dismissive or short-tempered over time, and occasional Patreon billing issues appear to go unresolved. Overall sentiment shows no meaningful shift from the prior reporting window; the show's formula remains as well-received as ever.
Apple4.9 · 2,383
Summary generated Sep 23, 2026
