Sincerely Supernatural Podcast
Jul 8, 2026 · 52 min · 10 segments
Two fishermen. One river. Two terrifying encounters.In this episode of Sincerely Supernatural, we investigate two eyewitness reports from New Jersey's Musconetcong River involving a mysterious…
And it was looking over hi- its shoulder at him.
And the whole time, from when he saw it to it going up the bank and moving away from him, it was getting less and less visible, as in like cloaking itself.
Like-
No
...
it was translucent.
[upbeat music] Welcome back to Sincerely Supernatural, where we talk about the strange, the mysterious, the unexplained, and all kinds of other things.
I'm your host, Seth.
And I'm Hudson, your other host.
And today Hudson's got something spooky.
Yeah.
I have a story today.
The what?
Musconetcong is the name of the river.
Musconetcong.
Oh, really? [laughs]
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Yeah.
But before we get into the story-
Mm-hmm
...
if you guys enjoy the video, if you could like and subscribe, and head over to Spotify and Apple Podcast, leave a review.
Read the full transcript.
Create an account to read the whole episode, search across every transcript, and follow the shows you care about.
And it was looking over hi- its shoulder at him.
And the whole time, from when he saw it to it going up the bank and moving away from him, it was getting less and less visible, as in like cloaking itself.
Like-
No
...
it was translucent.
[upbeat music] Welcome back to Sincerely Supernatural, where we talk about the strange, the mysterious, the unexplained, and all kinds of other things.
I'm your host, Seth.
And I'm Hudson, your other host.
And today Hudson's got something spooky.
Yeah.
I have a story today.
The what?
Musconetcong is the name of the river.
Musconetcong.
Oh, really? [laughs]
Mm-hmm.
Okay.
Yeah.
But before we get into the story-
Mm-hmm
...
if you guys enjoy the video, if you could like and subscribe, and head over to Spotify and Apple Podcast, leave a review.
