Listener sentiment
The most recent wave of ratings is uniformly enthusiastic, with listeners praising Season 10 ("Discount Dave") as masterfully told and emotionally gripping — a notable rebound from the sharply polarized reception that greeted the preceding Season 9, "Creation Myth," which dominated earlier reviews in this window. Season 9, about a woman's decision to remain childless, drew passionate responses on both sides: many listeners, especially those who identify as child-free or ambivalent about parenthood, found it deeply relatable, brave, and beautifully produced, while a vocal contingent dismissed the host as self-absorbed, privileged, and intellectually shallow, with some objecting to heavy sound design and sentimentality in later episodes. Across the broader catalog, the anthology format means reception varies by season, but when a story lands, listeners describe the storytelling as exceptional, intimate, and hard to stop listening to; recurring criticisms tend to involve pacing, structural bloat, audio-level inconsistencies, and occasional skepticism toward certain narrative premises.
Apple3.6 · 140
Summary generated Aug 1, 2026