Listener sentiment
Listener sentiment for "Our Little Edey" is deeply polarized, with a strong majority of reviewers expressing admiration for the Westbrook family's fight and praising the podcast for bringing attention to what they see as a botched or corrupt police investigation into a teenage girl's death in rural Tasmania. Many supporters describe the series as important, emotionally powerful journalism that exposes systemic failures in Australian law enforcement, and some listeners report travelling to Eden's memorial or petitioning for the case to be reopened. A smaller but vocal group of critics — including some self-identified locals — push back hard, arguing the podcast is one-sided, conspiracy-driven, and reluctant to engage with evidence of suicide; several accuse the hosts and the former pro bono lawyer, Peter Lavac, of exploiting the family's grief for publicity. Across both camps, the most widely shared criticism is structural: nearly every reviewer, positive and negative, flags severe repetition of the same interview audio across episodes, poor sound editing, and a sense that the story could have been told in a fraction of the episodes. The unexplained disappearance of Lavac from later seasons — with all references to him quietly removed — is a recurring source of frustration and suspicion among listeners who initially praised his involvement. More recent reviews of Season 2 echo these production complaints while also criticizing the parents for shifting focus toward personal grievances and political appearances at the expense of the case itself.
Apple3.6 · 201
Summary generated Sep 15, 2026
