Listener sentiment
Recent ratings for Off With Their Headlines are overwhelmingly positive, with the vast majority of reviewers giving top marks and describing the show as a standout in royal-news commentary. Listeners consistently praise co-hosts Meredith Constant and Amanda Matta for their natural chemistry, sharp humor, and rigorous research, noting that their backgrounds in media criticism and art history complement each other well. A recurring theme across dozens of reviews is appreciation for the show's media-literacy lens — listeners value that the hosts dissect how royal stories are framed by the press rather than simply reciting gossip, and many say it has changed how they consume news more broadly. The podcast appears to have built its audience largely through the hosts' established TikTok followings, with many reviewers describing themselves as long-time social-media fans who were excited by the collaboration. The handful of critical reviews are mostly one-off grievances: one listener felt coverage of Catherine's health was under-researched and insensitive, another found the show's framing of Harry and Meghan too one-sided, and a third was put off by political tangents. A single reviewer also flagged jarring ad placement, though this was an early-series complaint. Overall, the recent window reflects a highly enthusiastic, loyal listener base that sees the show as both entertaining and intellectually substantive.
Apple4.8 · 75
Summary generated Sep 12, 2026
