Listener sentiment
My Old Man Said commands exceptionally strong listener loyalty, with the vast majority of recent reviews praising its intelligent analysis, dry wit, and professional production as the standout Aston Villa podcast. Supporters consistently value the show's balanced perspective—fans rather than hype-men, offering insight without sensationalism—and David Michael's articulate hosting of what many describe as an engaging mix of on-pitch analysis, off-field coverage, and humor that makes the commute enjoyable. A persistent minority critique frames the show's skepticism as excessively negative, particularly observations that recent episodes have dwelled repetitively on ticket-price grievances despite Villa's sporting success, and some listeners dislike perceived hosts talking over one another. Recent listener feedback also flags newly added AI-generated music segments as off-putting, and occasional complaints surface around inconsistent release timing and a rigid format that doesn't evolve. On balance, the podcast remains beloved among its audience for intellectual rigor and entertainment value, though producers may want to recalibrate tone and format choices given feedback on negativity and production additions.
Apple4.7 · 123
Summary generated May 29, 2026