Listener sentiment
Listener sentiment has shifted markedly over the past two years, from near-universal enthusiasm to a increasingly divided audience. Earlier reviews — concentrated in 2022 and 2023 — overwhelmingly praised the show's relatable dating stories, natural banter, and the genuine friendship among hosts Katy, Colbie, and Adam, with many describing it as a comforting Friday ritual. Since mid-2024, however, a growing chorus of criticism has emerged around two intertwined themes: the show has drifted away from its original dating-focused format into aimless pop-culture chit-chat with no clear direction, and Katy's on-air behavior — frequently interrupting co-hosts, steering conversations toward herself and her relationship, and making dismissive remarks toward Adam — has become a persistent source of frustration for multiple reviewers writing independently over many months. Adam and Colbie consistently receive the most praise in recent reviews, with listeners asking for more airtime for both and noting that their grounded perspectives and humor increasingly carry the show. A loyal core of listeners still finds the casual, friend-group dynamic enjoyable, but the prevailing sentiment among recent reviewers is disappointment that a once-beloved dating podcast has lost its sense of purpose.
Apple3.9 · 120
Summary generated Jul 5, 2026
