Listener sentiment
Recent ratings tell a story of mounting frustration with repeated, unannounced host changes on what was long a beloved daily Predators podcast. The show built strong goodwill across three successive host eras — Robby Stanley's insider insight, Matt Best and Justin Bradford's entertaining banter, and Ann Kimmel and Emma Lingan's sharp analysis — each drawing enthusiastic five-star praise from dedicated listeners. The most recent reviews, however, mark a sharp downturn: listeners are upset not only that Ann and Emma departed without warning (with some noting they were a rare draw as female voices in hockey media), but that the latest replacement host has been criticized for lacking preparation and delivering unconvincing analysis, with one longtime listener describing the show as borderline unlistenable. The pattern of silent host swaps has become a recurring complaint in itself, and the sentiment has shifted from loyal enthusiasm to genuine disenchantment with the show's current direction.
Apple4.4 · 32
Summary generated Jul 18, 2026
