Recorded live on July 27, 2026.
David Pearce, the British philosopher who wrote The Hedonistic Imperative in 1995 and has spent the three decades since arguing that biotechnology should phase out suffering in all sentient life, joins Erik and Guy from Lisbon at ten at night. The radio hour builds the case from the ground up: what negative utilitarianism is (Pearce starts with the Buddha), why he wants to replace the pain-pleasure axis with a "pleasure-super-pleasure axis," what a hedonic set point is, and which genes are actually in play, from SCN9A, the "volume knob for pain," to the FAAH and FAAH-OUT mutations of Jo Cameron, the Scottish woman who barely feels pain. The podcast hour gets harder. Erik reports an argument he had with Claude before the show, raises elective disability, and finally asks the question Pearce himself once put to him: if suffering is all that matters, why not end all life? Guy brings a friend's hard prenatal decision and asks whether existence is a gift or a burden. Pearce answers everything with the same patience, plus one line worth keeping: "if you're not prepared to accept all the consequences of your preferred ethic, then get a better ethic."
Key Topics
- **\[00:00 - 02:09] Cold open**: the timeline that "tries to maximize its pleasure"; Guy hopes his suffering leaks out; Erik introduces David, who is calling from Lisbon at 10 PM
- **\[02:09 - 04:48] What negative utilitarianism is**: the Buddha's "suffering and the end of suffering" as the precept; no one needs to buy the whole theory to back the abolitionist project, just as everyone eventually backed pain-free surgery; "my agony and despair have a built-in normative aspect"
- **\[04:48 - 08:33] Where it started**: a blackbird pulling a worm from the garden when David was three or four; teenage fascination with wireheading (Olds and Milner's "pleasure centers"); the disappointment that friends did not want to be "intracranially self-stimulating rats"; the turn to information-sensitive gradients of well-being and genome reform
- **\[08:33 - 12:43] The hedonic set point**: the lottery paradox; a thermostat with heavy genetic loading; a "hyperthymic civilization"; Erik's summary; the first objection (don't we need pain to survive?) and the answer that nociception must be kept while pain is tamed
- **\[12:43 - 23:33] Signals without suffering**: lovemaking and generative AI art as signaling systems with no sub-zero experience; Guy on dopamine and character; wanting (dopamine) versus liking (the mu opioid system); a civilization running from +70 to +100; why pain versus suffering is a conventional line; Guy on two years when he could not feel good, and "I take the bliss"
- **\[23:33 - 30:03] The actual biology**: SCN9A, the "volume knob for pain," and its benign variants; China's CRISPR babies; embryo screening companies; screening versus germline editing; Jo Cameron's FAAH and FAAH-OUT mutations and anandamide
- **\[30:03 - 39:00] Anders Sandberg, the Happy Baby Company, and the radio close**: Anders, "happy when I'm angry"; hyperthymic is not manic; the company David would start if he were entrepreneurial; depression worldwide; somatic gene therapy for adults is decades from cheap; hedweb.com and "state-of-the-art web design around about 1996"
- **--- \[Act 2: Extended Conversation] ---**
- **\[39:00 - 49:36] What helps now, and an argument with Claude**: diet, exercise and sleep before drugs, and drugs with a specialist before gene therapy; Erik pushes back; Erik's pre-show argument with Claude about whether the Jo Cameron mutation raises a set point or only lowers pain; genes interact; David as a "soft antinatalist" who says "the future belongs to life lovers"; elective deafness and whether any choice should be illegal
- **\[49:36 - 58:00] A prenatal dilemma and the gift of existence**: Guy's friend facing a hard prenatal decision and finding no ground to choose from; David on disability and reported well-being; the narrowness of IQ; parents becoming responsible for their children's traits; Guy asks whether existence is a gift or a burden
- **\[58:00 - 1:06:00] Darwinian life, empathy, and forgetting suffering**: natural selection as "a vicious engine of suffering"; a third-generation vegetarian who rescued ants and worms on the tarmac; gene drives and a civilized biosphere; Guy asks whether suffering about suffering is good; MDMA, empathy, compassion and hypersystematizing; making suffering "literally inconceivable"
- **\[1:06:00 - 1:12:32] A pan-species welfare state**: herbivorizing the cat family with synthetic gene drives; vegan cats and dogs; "high-tech Jainism"; ending factory farms and slaughterhouses comes first
- **\[1:12:32 - 1:17:26] The spicy question**: why not end all life? Nobody asked the Buddha that; a negative utilitarian upholding the sanctity of life in law; the paperclipper; "get a better ethic"; the pinprick argument; the genie offer that a classical utilitarian must accept
- **\[1:17:26 - 1:25:07] Why he keeps making the case, and goodbyes**: hoping a billionaire or a big podcaster takes up the cause; anesthesia was controversial for about 15 years; Erik would take Anders's gene "in a second"; the WHO definition of health; "the E-word"; David's sign-off wish that their lives be "marked by immense joy and happiness"
Guest Bio
David Pearce (born 1959) is a British philosopher and the best-known advocate of what he calls the abolitionist project: using biotechnology to phase out suffering in all sentient life. His 1995 online manifesto, The Hedonistic Imperative, argues that genetic engineering, pharmacology and nanotechnology can replace the pain-pleasure axis with "information-sensitive gradients of bliss." In 1998 he co-founded the World Transhumanist Association with Nick Bostrom; the organization has been known as Humanity+ since 2008. He set up BLTC Research, a network of websites, in 1995, and still maintains hedweb.com. He approaches ethics as a negative utilitarian and, by his own account on the show, comes from three generations of vegetarians. He sits on several advisory boards, including the Qualia Research Institute's. He lives in Brighton, England; he joined this conversation from Lisbon. On X he is @webmasterdave.
Notable Moments
- **\[~02:40] The one-line definition.** "Gautama Buddha once said, I teach one thing and one thing only, suffering and the end of suffering, and negative utilitarianism is in one sense the systematization of that precept."
- **\[~05:24] The blackbird.** At three or four, David clapped his hands to scare a blackbird off a worm, then "felt vaguely foolish because I was aware that without the ability to eat, the blackbird would starve." The whole later project, predators included, is already in the scene.
- **\[~08:06] The pitch in one sentence.** "Just imagine waking up tomorrow morning in an extraordinarily good mood, but with your relationships, your preference architecture, and values intact."
- **\[~12:43] The self-description.** Asked how life could run without pain signals, David offers lovemaking as the example, prefaced: "though I'm a crashing prude and a celibate to boot."
- **\[~30:30] Anders Sandberg's set point.** Erik reports what Anders told him: "it's so high that I'm happy when I'm angry," which confuses people on the receiving end because he is smiling at them.
- **\[~42:42] Erik versus Claude.** Erik recounts arguing with Claude before the show about germline editing ("come on, Claude, come on. Really?") and lands on the one objection he found nuanced: we cann...