Listener sentiment
The Fantasy Footballers continues to draw overwhelming enthusiasm from a deeply loyal listener base, with the vast majority of recent reviewers calling it the best fantasy football podcast available and crediting hosts Andy Holloway, Jason Moore, and Mike Wright — along with the Ultimate Draft Kit — for league championships and years of consistent playoff berths. Reviewers repeatedly highlight the show's winning blend of sharp analysis and self-deprecating humor, describing it as a daily hangout with knowledgeable friends, and long-tenured listeners praise the varied segments, inside jokes, and the companion Spitballers podcast. A small but recurring thread of criticism has emerged in the latest weeks: multiple reviewers, even those still rating the show highly, note that Andy has been talking more this season and occasionally cutting off or talking over Jason and Mike. A handful of one-star reviews repeat earlier complaints about excessive ads, analysis that feels overly subjective, and a wish for a former host, while at least one listener pushed back explicitly to defend the show against its critics. These criticisms remain a minor current within a vast reservoir of loyal praise, but the note about host dynamics is new and worth monitoring.
Apple4.9 · 1,407
Summary generated Sep 24, 2026
