Sep 30, 2026 · 44 min · 15 segments
How do you know you're lost if you don’t even know you're missing? The remarkable story of Melissa Highsmith being found 51 years after being kidnapped as a baby made global headlines, but the…
First memory that I have is living in a house on a hill and me looking out the window and my big brother riding his tricycle
right off of Berry and Riverside.
I had my mom and her husband, which was a stepdad.
Then I had a big brother and a little brother.
Michael was the older one.
We were never really, really that close.
I was like something on the bottom of his shoe that he wanted to scrape off.
He didn't want to have nothing to do with me.
My little brother, Matthew, I don't remember him being born.
I just remember one day he was there.
He was a toddler and he was there.
But my house, I just remember as early as I can remember her telling me that I was special.
She would say that I was born at home and that my heart stopped breathing and that I was mentally retarded.
I grew up thinking that I was damaged.
I would look at other families and they were all loving and everything and I wondered, how come my mama doesn't love me? How come my brother doesn't love me?
All
my life I lived in the south side and it wasn't more than three or four miles max from where I was taken.
Imagine growing up and realizing you've never seen any of your baby pictures or a book with your first lock of hair or that first cute onesie.
Then imagine living in a house where a younger brother just showed up one day.
You don't remember him being born.
And then imagine a family, a mom, a stepdad, that something about all of this, about them, just didn't feel right.
If you had an entire city looking for you when you disappeared at just 21 months old, how would you even know you were lost? How would you know that your real mother and father, your real brothers and sisters, had been searching for you your entire life? How would you know? And what would you do once you found out? A
In 1971, 22-month-old Melissa Highsmith was abducted from her family in Fort Worth, Texas.
Melissa was after a disappearance that spanned 51 years.
First memory that I have is living in a house on a hill and me looking out the window and my big brother riding his tricycle
right off of Berry and Riverside.
I had my mom and her husband, which was a stepdad.
Then I had a big brother and a little brother.
Michael was the older one.
We were never really, really that close.
I was like something on the bottom of his shoe that he wanted to scrape off.
He didn't want to have nothing to do with me.
My little brother, Matthew, I don't remember him being born.
I just remember one day he was there.
He was a toddler and he was there.
But my house, I just remember as early as I can remember her telling me that I was special.
She would say that I was born at home and that my heart stopped breathing and that I was mentally retarded.
I grew up thinking that I was damaged.
I would look at other families and they were all loving and everything and I wondered, how come my mama doesn't love me? How come my brother doesn't love me?
All
my life I lived in the south side and it wasn't more than three or four miles max from where I was taken.
Imagine growing up and realizing you've never seen any of your baby pictures or a book with your first lock of hair or that first cute onesie.
Then imagine living in a house where a younger brother just showed up one day.
You don't remember him being born.
And then imagine a family, a mom, a stepdad, that something about all of this, about them, just didn't feel right.
If you had an entire city looking for you when you disappeared at just 21 months old, how would you even know you were lost? How would you know that your real mother and father, your real brothers and sisters, had been searching for you your entire life? How would you know? And what would you do once you found out? A
In 1971, 22-month-old Melissa Highsmith was abducted from her family in Fort Worth, Texas.
Melissa was after a disappearance that spanned 51 years.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.