Sep 28, 2026 · 1 hr 2 min · 22 segments
**THIS IS PART TWO OF TWO** As investigators pulled at the threads of Jesse's final weeks, they uncovered a secret he'd reportedly been ready to reveal. But the most stunning twist was still to come…
Now, Andy was super uncomfortable with whatever this is, but he remained silent as the officer aggressively grabbed Jesse and begins hooking up with him in front of him.
And soon, Andy's pulled in and the three of them are involved.
And the investigators don't believe the story at all.
They don't think it was a real cop.
They believe it had been a security guard, at least, or like Kimber said, a stripper.
It definitely wasn't one of their cops because they don't have any gay officers on the force.
But Andy insists this guy was a Columbia cop and that he was from their department and that this really did happen.
So they're like, okay, well then describe the officer.
And he's like, all I know is he's probably in his early 20s.
He's got dark hair.
It's kind of slightly receding.
He's slenderly built, not big and muscular, but not scrawny, just average.
And I mean, that is not very descriptive at all.
That could describe so many different people.
Andy thought it was just going to be the two of them.
Like usual, he would have never expected Jesse to bring someone else into the bedroom, especially a uniformed Columbia police officer.
And for Andy, this isn't a fun memory at all.
When he talks about it, he describes feeling nervous and shaken.
He was thinking, this guy's a cop, someone who can arrest you, lock you up, and take away your future.
That's why he came forward to the investigators and admitted all of this, even if it meant admitting that he was involved in the encounter.
And he says, this should never be discussed ever with anyone.
It will stay a secret between us.
And the way he said it was almost threatening to the point that Andy was trembling.
Now, Andy was super uncomfortable with whatever this is, but he remained silent as the officer aggressively grabbed Jesse and begins hooking up with him in front of him.
And soon, Andy's pulled in and the three of them are involved.
And the investigators don't believe the story at all.
They don't think it was a real cop.
They believe it had been a security guard, at least, or like Kimber said, a stripper.
It definitely wasn't one of their cops because they don't have any gay officers on the force.
But Andy insists this guy was a Columbia cop and that he was from their department and that this really did happen.
So they're like, okay, well then describe the officer.
And he's like, all I know is he's probably in his early 20s.
He's got dark hair.
It's kind of slightly receding.
He's slenderly built, not big and muscular, but not scrawny, just average.
And I mean, that is not very descriptive at all.
That could describe so many different people.
Andy thought it was just going to be the two of them.
Like usual, he would have never expected Jesse to bring someone else into the bedroom, especially a uniformed Columbia police officer.
And for Andy, this isn't a fun memory at all.
When he talks about it, he describes feeling nervous and shaken.
He was thinking, this guy's a cop, someone who can arrest you, lock you up, and take away your future.
That's why he came forward to the investigators and admitted all of this, even if it meant admitting that he was involved in the encounter.
And he says, this should never be discussed ever with anyone.
It will stay a secret between us.
And the way he said it was almost threatening to the point that Andy was trembling.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.