ENCORE: Why Giving Doesn't Make You Great

In this episode, Lisa revisits one of the earliest episodes of the podcast, originally titled "Why Giving Doesn't Make You Great," with a new introduction recorded after a conversation with a friend and former client at a conference in Calgary. That conversation centered on the children's book Rainbow Fish, in which a fish gives away each of his sparkly scales in order to be liked and accepted by the other fish.  Lisa connects this to the messages many women receive growing up: don't be too much, don't shine too brightly, but also don't shrink too far. She traces this back to core human needs for love, safety, and belonging, and invites listeners to examine where they learned that standing out put those needs at risk, and what parts of themselves they may have given away as a result. The original episode explores the theme of martyrdom and over-giving, using the children's book The Giving Tree as a central metaphor. Lisa unpacks how the tree gives away everything she has, her apples, her branches, her trunk, until she is left as a stump, and is still described as "happy." She connects this pattern to the belief that self-worth is tied to how much of yourself you can give away, and to the guilt and discomfort that surface when women begin prioritizing their own needs. A central story in the episode comes from a member of a coaching community Lisa is part of (through Jim Fortin's program), a woman named Kirsten who shared a personal realization after listening to an earlier episode of the podcast. Kirsten described coming from generations of self-sacrificing mothers and believing that giving all her love away, without keeping any for herself, was what love required. After an argument, her husband told her he might come to resent her if she didn't start taking care of herself, a moment Kirsten described as earth-shattering.  Lisa uses this story to introduce the idea that giving everything away isn't rooted in love, but in a belief in scarcity, and contrasts the metaphor of love as a finite pie with love as an unlimited, continuously flowing fountain. Lisa closes the episode by encouraging listeners to take an honest inventory of where they are over-giving, and to recognize that prioritizing their own wellbeing is not selfish, but a necessary condition for sustainable impact in their relationships, families, and work. Resources mentioned: - The Giving Tree, by Shel Silverstein - Rainbow Fish, by Marcus Pfister - Jim Fortin's coaching community Apply to work with Lisa 1:1: lisacarpenter.ca/wwm If you listen on Spotify:  1. Open the Spotify app on your phone. 2. Search for *Lisa Carpenter* and open her podcast page. 3. Tap the three dots under the podcast description. 4. Choose Rate show from the menu. 5. Select your star rating and tap Submit.