Listener sentiment
Catholic Saints continues to earn strong listener loyalty for its content, with reviewers consistently praising the Augustine Institute scholars' expertise, the accessible conversational format, and the breadth of coverage spanning well-known and obscure saints alike. Both Catholic and non-Catholic listeners say the show deepens their faith and fills gaps in their knowledge of Church history. The most recent ratings, however, show a slight downward drift driven by familiar production complaints that show no sign of abating: multiple reviewers cite excessive filler words (particularly "like" and "um"), hosts talking over or interrupting guests, rushed or mumbling delivery, and episodes that sound under-rehearsed. A newer thread of criticism has emerged around balance and accuracy: several reviewers flagged the St. Junípero Serra episode for glossing over the harm caused by the California missions, and others wish the show would present saints' flaws and struggles alongside their virtues rather than offering a uniformly hagiographic portrait. Episode repetition in the feed without clear labeling remains an ongoing frustration. The content is widely cherished; the delivery and editorial framing are where listeners want to see improvement.
Apple4.3 · 106
Summary generated Aug 23, 2026
