Sep 23, 2026 · 30 min · 11 segments
When a senior cat loses a longtime feline companion, it's natural for us to think, *"They're lonely. They need another cat."* But is that really what your cat needs? In this episode of **Cat Talk…
Have you ever had a cat who happily lived with another cat for years, and then that other cat died, and suddenly your surviving cat just isn't quite the same? You know, maybe they're sleeping more or hiding or not playing as much, or maybe they're just, you know, need more affection from you.
My cat needs another cat." And that's where today's conversation begins, 'cause I've had three consultations in the past 10 days involving almost exactly this scenario.
A senior cat loses its longtime feline companion, and the owners understandably believe their surviving cat is depressed or lonely, and they decide, "Let's get another cat." And very often, the cat they bring home is a kitten or a one-year-old or a few years old, and then everybody is confused when the senior cat says, "Excuse me? Who invited this lunatic into my house?" [laughs] So today we're gonna talk about something that I think is incredibly important for anyone living with an older cat.
Should you get another cat after your cat loses its companion? And if you do decide to bring another cat into the home, what should you consider, and how should you do it? And if you've already brought home that young cat and things have gone badly, well, we're gonna talk about that, too, because I don't want anybody listening to this thinking, "Oh, no, we made a terrible mistake.
We're already doomed." You're not doomed, but you may need to stop and back up and start over.
And we sometimes make the mistake of saying that cats are solitary animals, and therefore they don't care about other cats.
But that's too simplistic, all right? Because, you know, the, the more recent behavior science tells us that domestic cats are evolving in this area and that they really are socially flexible.
Some cats do prefer to live alone, and some just tolerate other cats or form loose social relationships, and some form extremely strong affiliative relationships with particular cats.
You know, you s- we know this when we see them sleeping with each other or allogrooming, which means grooming each other and, you know, rubbing against each other.
You know, just resting together, watching birds together, seeking each other out, you know? Um, actually, research on feline social organization has demonstrated that cats can perform preferential relationships with particular individuals.
And the 2024 AAFP Inner Cat Tension Guidelines emphasize that feline social relationships are highly individual, meaning a cat may have a close relationship with one cat and have very little interest or even conflict with another cat.
So when someone tells me, "But my cat loves other cats," I usually wanna ask which other cat, because that distinction is enormous.
Your cat might have loved Tabby or Mittens or Sophie, and that was a relationship between two individuals, and you cannot automatically recreate that relationship by putting another feline into the house.
Have you ever had a cat who happily lived with another cat for years, and then that other cat died, and suddenly your surviving cat just isn't quite the same? You know, maybe they're sleeping more or hiding or not playing as much, or maybe they're just, you know, need more affection from you.
My cat needs another cat." And that's where today's conversation begins, 'cause I've had three consultations in the past 10 days involving almost exactly this scenario.
A senior cat loses its longtime feline companion, and the owners understandably believe their surviving cat is depressed or lonely, and they decide, "Let's get another cat." And very often, the cat they bring home is a kitten or a one-year-old or a few years old, and then everybody is confused when the senior cat says, "Excuse me? Who invited this lunatic into my house?" [laughs] So today we're gonna talk about something that I think is incredibly important for anyone living with an older cat.
Should you get another cat after your cat loses its companion? And if you do decide to bring another cat into the home, what should you consider, and how should you do it? And if you've already brought home that young cat and things have gone badly, well, we're gonna talk about that, too, because I don't want anybody listening to this thinking, "Oh, no, we made a terrible mistake.
We're already doomed." You're not doomed, but you may need to stop and back up and start over.
And we sometimes make the mistake of saying that cats are solitary animals, and therefore they don't care about other cats.
But that's too simplistic, all right? Because, you know, the, the more recent behavior science tells us that domestic cats are evolving in this area and that they really are socially flexible.
Some cats do prefer to live alone, and some just tolerate other cats or form loose social relationships, and some form extremely strong affiliative relationships with particular cats.
You know, you s- we know this when we see them sleeping with each other or allogrooming, which means grooming each other and, you know, rubbing against each other.
You know, just resting together, watching birds together, seeking each other out, you know? Um, actually, research on feline social organization has demonstrated that cats can perform preferential relationships with particular individuals.
And the 2024 AAFP Inner Cat Tension Guidelines emphasize that feline social relationships are highly individual, meaning a cat may have a close relationship with one cat and have very little interest or even conflict with another cat.
So when someone tells me, "But my cat loves other cats," I usually wanna ask which other cat, because that distinction is enormous.
Your cat might have loved Tabby or Mittens or Sophie, and that was a relationship between two individuals, and you cannot automatically recreate that relationship by putting another feline into the house.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.