Bronwyn FletcherHost
And I want to start with something that happens very easily when we look back at a diet that didn't last.

And that is we jump to a conclusion or name a reason as to why the diet was abandoned.

But whatever the reason, we've ended up back eating in the way that we did before we started the diet.

And because we've got a reason that seems obvious, there doesn't seem to be much point in looking at what happened further.

When we don't look further, very useful clues for the causes of weight regain get lost.

So today I want to look at what happens when we stop treating a familiar explanation as the answer, and start asking whether it actually explains what happened.

There is a point after regaining weight when the explanation for it gets reduced to one-liners.

We say things like, I couldn't stick to it, or my sweet tooth did me in, or the other one that I really don't like to hear, and that is I fell off the wagon.

Sometimes you might be able to go a bit beneath the surface and remember that everything fell apart when you broke the diet by eating cake at a friend's birthday.

But whether the diet lasted a month or even a week, once the weight starts coming back, there isn't much mystery about it.

Now, when I spoke with Karen, she described herself as someone who was great at starting diets but not good at staying on them.

She would start a diet with enormous enthusiasm and then usually within a week it would come to an end.

Now, Karen is a woman who has spent years trying to solve the same problem, yet the only explanation she arrived at was that she simply couldn't stick to diets.

Now, on the surface of it, that solution for her problem looks pretty straightforward.

That is, except she's been trying to change her weight for years, and in those years she's done Weight Watchers twice, she's tried intermittent fasting and meal replacements, and there were several other diets she couldn't remember the names of.

She constantly reads about weight loss, and she's very open and frequently experiments with her own eating.

At one point she stopped having breakfast to try and reduce the overall calories for the day.

Yet this history that Karen described doesn't tell us what produced the weight regain.

And I want to start with something that happens very easily when we look back at a diet that didn't last.

And that is we jump to a conclusion or name a reason as to why the diet was abandoned.

But whatever the reason, we've ended up back eating in the way that we did before we started the diet.

And because we've got a reason that seems obvious, there doesn't seem to be much point in looking at what happened further.

When we don't look further, very useful clues for the causes of weight regain get lost.

So today I want to look at what happens when we stop treating a familiar explanation as the answer, and start asking whether it actually explains what happened.

There is a point after regaining weight when the explanation for it gets reduced to one-liners.

We say things like, I couldn't stick to it, or my sweet tooth did me in, or the other one that I really don't like to hear, and that is I fell off the wagon.

Sometimes you might be able to go a bit beneath the surface and remember that everything fell apart when you broke the diet by eating cake at a friend's birthday.

But whether the diet lasted a month or even a week, once the weight starts coming back, there isn't much mystery about it.

Now, when I spoke with Karen, she described herself as someone who was great at starting diets but not good at staying on them.

She would start a diet with enormous enthusiasm and then usually within a week it would come to an end.

Now, Karen is a woman who has spent years trying to solve the same problem, yet the only explanation she arrived at was that she simply couldn't stick to diets.

Now, on the surface of it, that solution for her problem looks pretty straightforward.

That is, except she's been trying to change her weight for years, and in those years she's done Weight Watchers twice, she's tried intermittent fasting and meal replacements, and there were several other diets she couldn't remember the names of.

She constantly reads about weight loss, and she's very open and frequently experiments with her own eating.

At one point she stopped having breakfast to try and reduce the overall calories for the day.

Yet this history that Karen described doesn't tell us what produced the weight regain.
The rest of this transcript — segmented and speaker-labeled, so you land on the exact moment something was said
Search every transcript — by keyword, by phrase, or by meaning, across every show Radar indexes
Trends — what is surging across podcasts, measured against its own baseline
Alerts — when a name you follow appears in a newly indexed episode
No account is needed to search Radar.