Listener sentiment
Listeners are overwhelmingly enthusiastic about this podcast, praising narrator Jon Hagadorn's engaging, easygoing delivery and the breadth of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle material he covers — from canonical Sherlock Holmes tales to lesser-known stories and vintage radio replays. Many reviewers describe it as an ideal companion for commutes, chores, walks, and unwinding at bedtime, and several say Hagadorn's voice has become the voice they associate with the characters. The most frequent criticism, recurring across multiple years of reviews, concerns advertising: listeners find the ads too long, jarringly loud, prone to cutting in mid-sentence, and occasionally off-putting when they are political or tonally mismatched with the cozy material. A smaller but persistent minority of reviewers — including some British listeners — feel Hagadorn's American accent and occasional mispronunciations undercut the authenticity of British stories, though many others find his style charming and actively prefer it to "scenery-chewing" voice acting. A few listeners have also flagged missing or incomplete episodes and a preference for Hagadorn's own narration over the vintage radio-show segments, but these are isolated concerns rather than a broad trend.
Apple4.7 · 133
Summary generated Jul 6, 2026