
Watcher in the Water
15
MENTIONS
3
EPISODES
2
PODCASTS
Search complete. 15 mentions across 3 episodes found for "Watcher in the Water".
Sep 17, 2026
Ranking the Top 10 Horrors in The Lord of the Rings | Deconstructing Horror
R
12:20Ryan DoesHOST
Number six, we're in the subgenre of kaiju now.
R
12:24Ryan DoesHOST
with The Watcher in the Water.
R
12:26Ryan DoesHOST
So Nick, what is The Watcher in the Water, and what about it is so horrifying?
N
12:30Nick PolkGUEST
Similarly with The Fell Beast, The Watcher in the Water is like, we don't know what it is.
N
12:36Nick PolkGUEST
It's kind of, but also another element that makes The Watcher in the Water terrifying is that it's its own thing.
N
12:44Nick PolkGUEST
It's debated within nerds about who reads all of the sacred Tolkien texts online, about what exactly is the Watcher in the Water.
N
12:55Nick PolkGUEST
Is the Watcher in the Water a servant of Sauron? Is it influenced by Sauron? Most consensus is that it's just a horrible monster from the depths of the Earth that basically is so powerful and terrifying and untamable that it just exists as similar to the fel beast a sort of cosmic horror entity yeah
R
13:24Ryan DoesHOST
you keep bringing up cosmic horror and i think that's actually instead of kaiju we'll get to a kaiju instead of kaiju that almost makes me think more lovecraft how he describes the deep ones and the the the ancient unknowable monsters of the depths The fact that, you know, you who have done a good, healthy amount of, of research and writing in the sphere of Tolkien, it was like watching the water is the watcher in the water.
(Video) 250 - Forgotten Tyranids Species
F
64:09FishyPANELIST
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
H
64:10HadiGUEST
It's, it's like a cross between the Sarlacc and the Watcher in the Water from Lord of the Rings.
H
64:15HadiGUEST
So you know, obviously, the Sarlacc-
M
64:16MarkHOST
Yeah
H
64:21HadiGUEST
Obviously it's got all the, the bit underneath the sand, like all the chambers and stuff that, you know, Boba Fett escapes from.
H
64:26HadiGUEST
So, so you've got all that.
H
64:28HadiGUEST
But then, um, so, you know, like you said, the tip of an iceberg, but then you've got the Watcher in the Water and the fact that, like, it just sits there watching.
H
64:36HadiGUEST
It's got, like, a little periscope type thing, and then all of a sudden it just leaps out-
250 - Forgotten Tyranids Species
F
67:10FishyPANELIST
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
H
67:11HadiGUEST
It's, it's like a cross between the Sarlacc and the Watcher in the Water from Lord of the Rings.
H
67:15HadiGUEST
So you know, obviously, the Sarlacc-
M
67:17MarkHOST
Yeah
H
67:17HadiGUEST
... uh, obviously you've got the weird butthole thing on the sand in Star Wars.
H
67:21HadiGUEST
But by, obviously it's got all the, the bit underneath the sand, like all the chambers and stuff that, you know, Boba Fett escapes from.
H
67:27HadiGUEST
So, so you've got all that, but then, um, so you know, like you said, the tip of an iceberg, but then you've got the Watcher in the Water and the fact that, like, it just sits there watching.
H
67:36HadiGUEST
It's got, like, a little periscope type thing, and then all of a sudden it just leaps out-