Skip to main content
Tyson C. Langhofer

Tyson C. Langhofer

Defender

Oct 9, 2026

44:35
Tell us what this policy actually does and what it means for these students day to day.
44:42
Sure.
44:43
Well, the, uh, equal treatment isn't a suggestion.
44:47
It's a requirement of the First Amendment.
44:49
But unfortunately here, Virginia state officials have singled out Christian groups, and only Christian groups, to be deprived of the benefits that every other student organization have.
45:00
These student groups, Bethel Campus Fellowship and Women of Victory, have been recognized student organizations on campus for many years, and being a recognized organization gives you the right to access student fee funds, to be able to reserve rooms, to be able to advertise, uh, your events, and to be able to affiliate with outside organizations.
45:19
But this campus ministries policy singled out Christian groups and es- uh, specifically exempted the Muslim Students Association from these restrictions, and then placed these restrictions on student groups, uh, that were Christian solely because they're Christian.
48:54
Tell us what happened that day, and how did school officials respond when her mother reported it?
6:00
Can you unpack that part for us?
6:01
Sure.
6:01
It's, it's sort of a crazy set of facts.
6:03
So after the initial teacher complained, the school ordered him to remove the books.
6:07
Uh, we then filed a lawsuit on behalf of Rod, and the, the district court actually ruled in Rod's favor and said that Rod could display the books when the students that he was serving were not present.
6:19
So in other words, when he wasn't testing students in his office, he could display them.
6:22
He had to remove them while he, while he was serving them.
7:14
What happened there? How did it rule?
Casey MattoxMODERATOR
14:19
Who wins that fight? And how does academic freedom sort of inform that question?
14:26
Well, that's a great question.
14:28
I think obviously that sums up the entire debate we're talking about here, right? Because as Joe noted, and as you noted, there are multiple organizations, individuals, representative groups that all have an interest in in promoting the education of the next generation.
14:48
And in some way, they all have some version of academic freedom.
14:52
And I and I and, you know, where that balancing lies, I think, is what these courts are grappling with.
14:59
Right.
14:59
Because obviously, this state does have an interest because it spends hundreds of millions of dollars every year in educating the next generation.

13 MINS LATER

Casey MattoxMODERATOR
28:24
So, Tyson, if you can speak to that and sort of what the special kind of status at this point of universities is after the Garcetti decision.
Roger SeverinoMODERATOR
2:57
So tell me in particular what facts drove you to get involved and where, where the case stands now in your dealings with Loudoun County.
3:05
Sure.
3:05
Thanks, Roger.
3:07
So, um, in my role as the center, uh, you know, as the, w- formerly as the director of the Center for Academic Freedom, and now with the Center for Free Speech at Alliance Defending Freedom, we defend the rights of students and faculty at public schools, K through 12, plus public universities.
3:22
And one of the things that we've seen over the last seven to eight years, where the majority of these, uh, free speech, uh, free exercise, and parental rights issues arise in the, is in the issue of gender identity and the policies being adopted by schools and how those impact those various rights.
3:40
And so what, um, we saw, i- as you said, we're, we go back to May of twenty twenty-one, um, Loudoun County was considering at that point in time a adopting a gender identity policy.
3:54
Now at that time, um, Gover- Governor Northam and their Department of Education had issued some model policies, and according to those model policies, it was requiring school districts to adopt policies which essentially required teachers to use the names, uh, preferred names and pronouns that students request and that they didn't have to have parental permission beforehand.

25 MINS LATER

Roger SeverinoMODERATOR
29:46
What is your sense of that, and also what do you think the next battleground is gonna be on parental rights and gender ideology?
13:47
So first, can you give us sort of a top-line summary of this? What is this curriculum that sparked this backlash from parents?
13:54
Sure.
13:54
Well, the curriculum is entitled Rights, Respect, and Responsibility, the three R's.
14:00
Sounds like a great civics, uh, lesson, right? Uh, it, it sounds pretty innocuous, but when you dig into it, what it actually is is a comprehensive sexual education program that starts from kindergarten and goes all the way through high school.
14:14
And the problem is that the school has made a... created this very difficult opt-out system for parents.
14:22
And so parents who object to the curriculum them- itself is having a very difficult time, uh, you know, knowing how to opt their, their children out of this program that they would rather them not be in.
16:13
And to be clear, this is not a lawsuit, so no courts or judges are involved at this point.
16:18
That's correct.
9:03
Here's what he said.
9:04
The Department of Education is right to be concerned about the many problems facing higher education, and I'm glad that they're recognizing that the, uh, student loan program, you know, may have contributed to the rise in cost and that they should evaluate it to, to, to determine whether the program is helping students or is it harming students.
9:23
At the same time, I, I think that the department should make sure that it, it's not, uh, reducing the value of education to simply a calculation of how much a degree would earn somebody, and this is especially true when it comes to religious education because we know that, that religion contributes much more to society than, than simply can be determined by the value of a pastor's salary.
20:24
How did you guys hear about this incident, and why did you choose to get involved?
20:28
Well, uh, because, you know, n- high school students should be encouraged to share their beliefs and the, and opinions on really important topics.
20:36
But they shouldn't be censored by government officials who disagree with their opinions, and the school here has created an, uh, an opportunity on their Spirit Rock for students to share their beliefs, yet they didn't like what Gabby had to say.
20:49
And so, because of that, they not only censored her by painting over the rock, but they then sent out an email to the entire school community accusing her of vandalism and saying that they have started a criminal investigation.
21:00
The next day at school, they called her into the principal's office, and they demanded that she write out a statement without, you know, reading her her rights or telling her she's under criminal investigation, like, telling her that she has the right to an attorney or telling her she has the right to remain silent.
21:13
That's, that's a problem, right? Because the school officials have created this forum, yet they're saying, "Because you share this opinion, we're not gonna let you participate in that forum." That's a violation of the First Amendment, it should never happen in America, and we wanna hold these school official-hals- officials accountable for doing that.
23:45
I have to wonder, uh, are there examples on this spirit rock that, you know, maybe celebrated LGBTQ? Are there examples of, you know, things that maybe conservatives wouldn't find so appealing, and were there any consequences for, for those, those demonstrations?
24:01
So, uh, several years ago, during the, uh, BLM movement, there were, there were BLM...
117:44
So I was asking, how did you hear about this incident and why did Alliance Defending Freedom choose to get involved?
117:50
Well, because high school students should be encouraged to share their beliefs and opinions on really important topics, but they shouldn't be censored by government officials who disagree with their opinions.
118:02
And the school here has created an opportunity on their spirit rock for students to share their beliefs.
118:08
Yet they didn't like what Gabby had to say.
118:10
And so because of that, they not only censored her by painting over the rock, but they then sent out an email to the entire school community, accusing her of vandalism and saying that they have started a criminal investigation.
118:22
The next day at school, they called her into the principal's office and they demanded that she write out a statement without reading her rights or telling her she's under criminal investigation, telling her that she has the right to an attorney or telling her she has the right to remain silent.
118:35
That's a problem, right? Because the school officials have created this forum, yet they're saying, because you share this opinion, we're not going to let you participate in that forum.
121:09
I have to wonder, are there examples on this podcast spirit rock that, you know, maybe celebrated LGBTQ? Are there examples of, you know, things that maybe conservatives wouldn't find so appealing? And were there any consequences for those demonstrations?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.