
thestral
28
MENTIONS
12
EPISODES
9
PODCASTS
Search complete. 28 mentions across 12 episodes found for "thestral".
Nov 19, 2026
Biggest Movie Plot Holes
J
18:01Juan NaulaNARRATOR
Yes, I'm Hufflepuff, how could you tell? Anyway, in the fifth movie, 2007's Order of the Phoenix, Harry discovers the truth behind the seemingly self-driving school carriages.
J
18:11Juan NaulaNARRATOR
It's not an enchantment, but strange creatures known as Thestrals that are responsible.
J
18:16Juan NaulaNARRATOR
The spooky horse-like beasts are totally invisible to anybody that has never seen death.
J
18:21Juan NaulaNARRATOR
But because Harry witnessed the tragic passing of Cedric at the end of the previous movie, he can now see them clearly.
J
18:28Juan NaulaNARRATOR
RIP Big Cedric! But the plot hole emerges when you realize that an integral part of Harry's backstory is that he witnessed his mother's demise when he was a baby.
J
18:37Juan NaulaNARRATOR
In that case, surely he'd have been able to see the Thestrals from day one? And even if we do accept he needed to watch Cedric die, shouldn't he have seen them at the end of the previous movie? Fans have been debating the issue since the movie first released, but the plot hole was actually already explained.
J
18:54Juan NaulaNARRATOR
Seen in 2004 shortly after the release of the book, author J.K. Rowling answered this very question.
J
19:00Juan NaulaNARRATOR
She claimed that it's not enough to witness death, one needs to comprehend it.
The Filthy Mudbloods – Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone Chapter 5-6
R
21:03Ryan KinelPANELIST
How, Hagrid? Yeah.
R
21:06Ryan KinelPANELIST
Like, the only thing I can think of is that a Thestral dropped him off.
R
21:14Ryan KinelPANELIST
Maybe.
R
21:14Ryan KinelPANELIST
Maybe.
Barovia V #16 You Only Remember It Because You Don't
J
39:04JacksonGUEST
Good luck, everybody.
S
39:05speaker_3GUEST
Thank you, Thestral.
S
39:06speaker_3GUEST
I mean, I trust you to look after the kids, but, you know, getting them to Velika in one piece, it's the important thing.
A
39:13Adam CarnevaleHOST
Thastrail nods.
A
41:40Adam CarnevaleHOST
That's it.
A
41:41Adam CarnevaleHOST
How long does it last? It lasts for a minute when you activate it.
S
41:45speaker_3GUEST
Thanks, Thestral.
S
41:46speaker_3GUEST
Appreciate it.
5 Massive Harry Potter Movie Mistakes HBO's Reboot Can Fix
S
5:36Seamus GormanHOST
particularly during large battles and from a cinematic perspective I understand the appeal but by contrast it also makes Voldemort's genuine ability to fly a lot less extraordinary for example Voldemort is first shown flying without a broomstick or other magical support during the battle of the seven potters and this is an important moment in the book because Harry realizes that Voldemort is doing something that ordinary witches and wizards aren't supposed to be capable of And then Harry saw him.
S
6:03Seamus GormanHOST
Voldemort was flying like smoke on the wind, without broomstick or Thestral to hold him, his snake-like face gleaming out of the blackness, his white fingers raising his wand again.
S
6:13Seamus GormanHOST
And later in the books, we see evidence that Snape had learned the ability as well.
S
6:18speaker_0ADVERTISER
Flowing ad budget on metrics that look great, till the CFO sees them, that's bull's bend.
One Page at at Time: Book 5, Page 500
A
2:27AliceHOST
Yeah, true.
A
2:28AliceHOST
But we did kind of accurately predict that.
A
2:29AliceHOST
We said it could be something with the Thestrals, didn't we?
M
2:32MarthaHOST
Yeah, and we also said something about Luna's introduction, so we're not quite to her introduction, I guess.
M
2:38MarthaHOST
We're a little past her introduction, but...
A
2:41AliceHOST
Yes, but Luna is here and we've got the Thestrals kind of mentioned.
A
2:49AliceHOST
But before we get into all of that, we've got a lot of band and album name drama to catch up
M
2:54MarthaHOST
on.
Chapter 21: The Unknowable Room | Half-Blood Prince
B
17:07Benjamin CarlinHOST
Correct.
B
17:07Benjamin CarlinHOST
It's very much like the Thestral situation where I feel like they kind of get like bad branding, right? But they pretty much just signal when it's about to rain
J
17:16Jonathan CarlinHOST
when it's about to rain.
J
17:17Jonathan CarlinHOST
That's that's like sort of their thing.
5 HUGE Harry Potter Plot Holes HBO's Reboot Can FIX
S
7:59Seamus GormanHOST
All they need to do is add a few additional lines explaining how the ministry handles it.
S
8:04Seamus GormanHOST
Next up, we've got one of the most commonly discussed plot holes, why couldn't Harry see the Thestrals? Reddit user CSalary2027 raised the question of why Harry couldn't see the Thestrals at the end of Godwood of Fire, despite having witnessed Cedric Diggory's death, only to then suddenly see them at the beginning of Order of the Phoenix.
S
8:22Seamus GormanHOST
Harry not being able to see the Thestrals in the end of Godwood of Fire, only to see them in the beginning of Order of the Phoenix.
S
8:28Seamus GormanHOST
Unfortunately, I've covered this one before in detail, and JK Rowling has actually addressed the issue herself.
S
8:34Seamus GormanHOST
For those unfamiliar, Thestrals are a breed of winged horse with skeletal features that pull the carriages transporting students between Hogsmeade Station and Hogwarts.
S
8:43Seamus GormanHOST
But the unusual thing about these creatures is that they're invisible to most people.
S
8:47Seamus GormanHOST
In fact, according to the books, they can only be seen by someone who has witnessed and understood death.
S
9:22Seamus GormanHOST
and when he returns for his fifth year, the creatures suddenly become visible to him.
Bill Weasley
R
56:31ReneeHOST
Yeah, I love Oliver Wood.
R
56:34ReneeHOST
Should we talk about a few theories about Bill? so the biggest theory that I found or like open-ended question was how can Bill Weasley see Thestrals so in the beginning of book seven Bill and Fleur ride on a Thestral from the Dursleys we like we know this to be true so I think the fandom is assuming that he at least and maybe her can see can see what they're riding on we know that you can technically ride one without being able to see it um but like can just bill see them and if he can see them who do you think he saw die or i you know fleur's there too but
J
57:19JessHOST
so i'm assuming that fleur maybe can't see them and bill helped her get on it or something but i would say bill could have seen someone die during his curse breaking journey you know he was in egypt like dealing with pretty dark magic or like ancient magic
R
57:36ReneeHOST
So
R
59:01ReneeHOST
mean obviously he sees mad eye get killed but that's like maybe they're
J
59:05JessHOST
fucking maybe they have like a torture chamber in that green gods i mean there's fucking oh maybe a dragon fucking eviscerated a goblin or killed someone right next to him and it was just like whoa we're working
R
59:19ReneeHOST
here is you know the risk but yeah but that makes me think too if Fleur couldn't see Thestrals she sees Mad-Eye die while she's on a Thestrals so she if she didn't see what she's seeing it now it'd be like it would be like fully registering for her like oh my
J
59:34JessHOST
god like we really did just see him die yeah yeah
Frankie McNair Helps Us Finger Paint
C
29:36Cory Peter LaneHOST
It's like in Harry Potter, the people who can see the evil.
C
29:38Cory Peter LaneHOST
The Thestrals? The Thestrals.
C
29:39Cory Peter LaneHOST
Yeah.
C
29:41Cory Peter LaneHOST
So I have an ability to see things.
One Page at at Time: Book 4, Page 723
A
57:16AliceHOST
Yeah.
A
57:16AliceHOST
Seeing the Quibbler or possibly the Thestrals.
A
57:19AliceHOST
Yeah.
A
57:19AliceHOST
Yeah.
2 more episodes mention thestral.
Create an account to see the whole feed, search across every transcript, and follow the entities you care about.