Skip to main content
Stella O'Malley

Stella O'Malley

Irish psychotherapist and author

Nov 9, 2026

5:51
Make me look completely ridiculous, please.
5:54
I'd start by saying I'm also a free speech advocate.
5:57
And you know, I wrote an email, I wrote an article about it in 2017.
6:00
And as a result, I was invited to do a documentary in 2018, which was released in the UK in 2018 about this.
6:07
And the premise of it, I'm going the long way around this answer.
6:10
And the premise of the, of the, of the, documentary, it's called Trans Kids, it's time to talk, was could any of this 4,000% rise in teenage girls seeking medical transition, could any of them be like me? Because I seem to be obsessed with being a boy from the age of three right through to puberty.
6:27
I was utterly miserable.

8 MINS LATER

speaker_2NARRATOR
14:17
for some years as a kid,
13:00
So what am I missing here?
13:03
Well, the fact is that you could get quite evolutionary about this.
13:09
Women do seem to understand the need for group cohesion more than men.
13:15
Arguably, women need the tribe more.
13:17
We need the community more than men.
13:19
And so women tend to be to be more appeasing.
13:23
We tend to be more.

10 MINS LATER

23:21
But conversion therapy laws are basically being used as a hammer to try and, you know, slam down any dissent or any disagreement with trans ideology, isn't it?
2:13
Tell us what that was about in brief.
2:15
So this is Peter Guydex and he's from Canada and he was a gay man who kind of came of age during the AIDS crisis.
2:24
He also had a difficult childhood and he sought, in the midst of his kind of coming to terms with his sexual orientation, he sought therapy and he had the misfortune to have a therapist who was very abusive, who kind of ran this kind of therapeutic cult house where they were all living in the house together.
2:45
And he was a psychologist, he was accredited, but he carried out like extraordinarily abusive practices on everybody in the house.
2:53
They were washing his clothes and they were cleaning his house.
2:57
And they had a kind of a primal screen basement.
3:01
They brought in this woman who was going to be some sort of maternal figure and they hugged her.

8 MINS LATER

11:18
Is that right?
21:42
But I wonder, is that consensus? It's no longer ethically tenable, is it, when you see figures as frail as Ariana Grande and she's not alone?
21:52
Yeah, because there's a difference between speaking about a woman's body in a magazine type way saying, has she put on, you know, Battle of the Bulge, has she put on a couple of inches versus somebody seems to be very unwell and it's quite visible.
22:08
And I do think that we need to be allowed to.
22:12
to speak about any sort of mental illness without shame and with clarity and honesty.
22:19
I don't think it's actually very helpful for it to be taboo to speak about somebody.
22:24
When you look at Karen Carpenter, And she died of anorexia.
22:28
She was the person who brought a huge amount of understanding to the masses about anorexia.

11 MINS LATER

33:10
And so it does beg the question that why do they think it's appropriate when I'm thin, but not when I'm not thin? Does that make sense?
1:59
The other one just can't wait to get back to Tullamore.
2:02
And often can't even articulate why.
2:03
Just get me back home.
2:05
Generally, we have kind of fairly solid motivation factors in life.
2:09
And some of us like challenge, fun, newness.
2:12
Some of us like security and kind of the sense of the familiar.
2:17
And so between Johnny and Mikey, Johnny likes the familiar.
7:06
Can you find yourself in a situation where you move to another country, you really want to make it work, but you're still suffering from homesickness? Can you wean yourself off it? Can you reduce it?
1:59
The other one just can't wait to get back to Tullamore.
2:02
And often can't even articulate why.
2:03
Just get me back home.
2:05
Generally, we have kind of fairly solid motivation factors in life.
2:09
And some of us like challenge, fun, newness.
2:12
Some of us like security and kind of the sense of the familiar.
2:17
And so between Johnny and Mikey, Johnny likes the familiar.
7:06
Can you find yourself in a situation where you move to another country, you really want to make it work, but you're still suffering from homesickness? Can you wean yourself off it? Can you reduce it?
Les SillarsHOST
16:18
The Detrans Awareness Conference is trying to pull them together in the US and around the world.
16:23
You say there's a gathering storm of much more people who are all getting to know each other because we're all online, and we're saying, "Hang on, I'm not the only one." [upbeat music]
Les SillarsHOST
18:23
Here's O'Malley once again.
18:25
And before they were always ashamed, beaten, beaten by the system, and now they're hearing from groups like Genspect who say, "No, no, no, no, no.
18:36
The medic- medics, the clinicians were wrong.
18:39
They should not have given you medical interventions that were not appropriate." And so our position is that, no, it, it wasn't appropriate to give somebody who had all these other diagnosis and who was in a highly traumatized state, it wasn't appropriate to, to allow them to believe that they could become the opposite sex when it was never gonna work out.
Les SillarsHOST
20:28
She's a psychotherapist in Ireland.
20:30
You could say it went back from the '80s, but really since 2010, to de-psychopathologize gender issues.
20:37
That meant this is not a mental illness.
20:40
This is just an ordinary and healthy, normal identity that needs to be, uh, supported in society.
20:45
This wasn't as a result of scientific inquiry.
20:48
It was as a result of political lobbying from WPATH that started in 2010, and it's been very, very, very successful.
Les SillarsHOST
20:55
Genspect and other opponents are trying to re-pathologize gender dysphoria.
21:00
Because it is a mental illness.
39:59
Jerry Armanick, who wrote a column about the National Post, he got suckered in and he described how at the end of the interview, the guy started counting out hundreds, like some kind of, first of all, I don't know anybody who uses cash anymore, but presumably they did it in order to kind of disguise their identity because if they wrote a check, I don't know, it's somehow.
40:17
Wow.
40:18
Where do you think we're going with all of this? Do you think it's going to get worse or will there be a backlash? I often think of 1970s Britain as, three day week and closed down and turned off the electricity and rubbish was on the street.
40:32
And then what happened was Margaret Thatcher happened.
40:35
You know what I mean? Like an extraordinarily different political regime came in.

11 MINS LATER

51:11
It was ever thus.
51:12
Yeah.
51:12
And one thing I felt real kind of just like yourself around looking for heartwarming.
3:23
Okay, you kind of tweeted about this story yesterday, and John Snow, who sadly has Alzheimer's, and we wish his family and him well in relation to that, but you tweeted in relation to the story of the surrogacy yesterday, So firstly, do you have an issue with surrogacy per se? And is it just, I suppose, the commercial surrogacy or have you an issue with philanthropic surrogacy? You know, I mean, do you have an issue with surrogacy?
3:47
I do.
3:48
I have an issue with third party reproduction.
3:50
I do think that like, you know, when you have a child, an awful lot happens that we don't know about.
4:00
And the bond that a mother and a father have that a biological child is not something to be taken lightly.
4:06
I think adoption is extraordinary and a beautiful process that can take place.
4:11
I also think sometimes that we do need help sometimes to have a baby.

8 MINS LATER

11:56
So you can have a baby whatever age you want.
13:33
question?
13:34
No, it's right on target because there's a striking similarity among this cohort, striking similarity of certain traits.
13:46
Probably the most common trait that one would notice is autistic traits.
13:50
And the, you know, the elevated proportion of young people seeking transition who are also autistic, it's extraordinary.
13:59
It depends on the clinic, you beyond 70% in another.
14:06
And then there are other, they often have other diagnoses like ADHD is very, very high as well.
14:13
And anxiety, eating disorders.
18:59
Uh, Everyone's story is unique, but if you could give a common composite case, what is the arc of Mary to Charles back to Mary? And if you could limit this, because I want to talk later about families and how families play into all this, but in the mind of the Mary, of Mary, Charles, Mary, what are they going through in this arc?
2:46
And can this vary from person to person in their perception of what is bad for them? And I'm putting bad in inverted commas there in the sense that person A can be sweating every night of the week because they've drunk so much and person B says, well, I have a glass of wine on a Saturday and I'm really worried about it.
3:04
Yeah, massively.
3:05
And some people are incredibly self-indulgent.
3:08
So they think what they're doing is perfectly fine while they're actually lowering way too much down their throat.
3:15
So yeah, it definitely depends on the person, their background, their values, how they've been raised, what they've kind of brought in in their own society, in their own company of what they think is a problem.
3:26
But I do think that the more people...
3:30
I love the concept of Lent because it's go on then, pick something.

6 MINS LATER

9:27
Is there anything one can do to make yourself think less about it?
2:29
And we know that.
2:30
No, we don't know that.
2:31
We don't have research for that.
2:33
What I have is an awful lot of clinical experience.
2:38
Running Genspect, you're kind of in touch with an awful lot of not only parents, but people who've gone through it.
2:45
You meet an awful lot of detransitioners.
2:47
We have an organization within Genspect called Beyond Trans and we offer funding for detransitioners and people who've been harmed by medical transition.
4:53
girls, younger children, and more men seem to transition to want to be women as adults?
7:20
And that's what their argument would be, that we're not going to discriminate, even though a child who is not capable of tying their shoelaces now can change their gender.
7:28
Yeah, well, there's a difference between discriminating and being judicious.
7:31
And we have to be judicious when we're working with children or involved with children or making any sort of policies around children.
7:37
And that's the issue.
7:38
If a five-year-old says that they're Let's say a little feminine little boy and he runs around in fairy dresses and he has a magic wand and he says he's actually really a girl.
7:48
That's perfectly normal child's play.
7:51
You know, these are these are children who are still into the, you know, the tooth fairy insanity.

16 MINS LATER

23:42
But so are they reversible? Or is there different brands of them? Or how does that work?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.