Skip to main content

Simon James Judkins

Psychologist

Nov 9, 2026

38:11
Explain how this plays out more broadly, particularly in relation to public hospitals.
38:18
Yeah, thanks very much for that.
38:20
And thanks so much for having us on.
38:22
And thanks to Alex, who put the great article together with Harold's son.
38:26
Look, I think there are a number of indicators that we have been very concerned about that just indicates how stretched that hospital system is.
38:34
And a lot of that is mentioned in the article.
38:36
Things like patients spending a day in our emergency departments waiting for an inpatient bed.
40:35
Now, if you're not coming out of the ward and going home, you're not coming from the ED up to the ward and you're not coming out of the ambulance into the ED, surely one of the quick solutions is money immediately available to have inpatient transfers to get people out of the wards and home, especially our elderly, over weekends
18:09
What's number one item on the agenda?
18:11
Well, I think we've got 10 number one items on the agenda.
18:14
I think what we're trying to point out to not only the Carroll government, but anybody, any political party who wants to be in government, that there's a range of health care reforms that AMA are advocating for to ensure that our healthcare system doesn't, continues to match, I guess, the standard that we're used to.
18:31
Such as? Well, we want to see better access, obviously, you know, the big ticket items around access into emergency department and hospital capacity, but we want to boost resourcing and regional and rural healthcare and improve the IT infrastructure to allow better communications about patient care, access into GPs, healthcare prevention.
18:50
There's a lot of different things on our agenda.
19:51
So, Doctor, do you track the deterioration? As in, can you show the parties numbers, or is it just a sense that there's a deterioration?
20:00
Well, certainly things like our access, our 24-hour stays in emergency departments, which have gone up to $3,500 every quarter, 3,500 patients across the state every quarter.
20:10
That is a significant deterioration over the last few years.
1:01
So, Doctor, do you go around the world and say, what does best practice look like, and then say, we want a bit of that?
1:07
I think we've got a lot of stuff in Victoria and Australia that is best practice, but what we're really worried about is that we're seeing a deterioration in a lot of those areas.
1:14
So particularly, as I said, in access into GPs and healthcare prevention and ensuring that people get access into, as I said, emergency care and access into specialist care.
1:23
So I think there's enough here for us to work on that we can continue to work with each political party to ensure that Victorians continue to get excellent healthcare.
2:03
So, Doctor, do you track the deterioration? As in, can you show the parties numbers, or is it just a sense that there's a deterioration?
2:12
Well, certainly things like our access, our 24-hour stays in emergency departments, which have gone up to $3,500 every... ..3,500 patients across the state every quarter.
2:22
That is a significant deterioration over the last few years.
2:24
So we know that 24-hour stays in emergency departments is a sign of healthcare system failure.
94:09
So I imagine it's harder to get an agreement with any government when you can't really strike that would lead to putting patients at risk, right?
94:19
Yeah, I think that's one of the things we've always struggled with is getting that balance right.
94:23
A lot of this industrial action with this EBA was about safer working conditions for doctors, so to enable them to deliver safer care, and it's been finding that balance.
94:34
You know, the government has always relied on the fact that doctors, you know, will err on that side of caution and not take action like strike action, but we've been forced into it.
94:44
This is a last-minute sort of decision not to go ahead with the strike action tomorrow, but, you know, nobody's happy about this deal.
94:51
This is only, you know, an interim agreement until we continue to battle with whoever is in government after this election.
94:59
So, yes, it certainly is something...
97:25
What have you actually accepted?
LivHOST
31:37
What's the union asking the government for and why now?
31:43
Essentially we're asking the government to give an end to this ongoing negotiations.
31:49
We need a resolution and we need a way forward.
31:52
As you just said the negotiations started 16 months ago and the expiry date I guess on the last EBA was March of this year so you know clearly we we start these negotiations early with the anticipation, the expectation that with, you know, a six-month period, we'd get to some position that we can agree on.
32:15
But unfortunately, that has just become an ongoing problem.
32:21
as we kept on turning up to meetings with VHIA representatives and government representatives every week and worked our way through terms and conditions and remuneration issues.
32:33
And we continued to not see an offer on the table until we started to really escalate and start talking about industrial actions.

6 MINS LATER

LivHOST
38:59
What does that say about the government's attitude towards public health workers as a whole?
46:46
So why isn't it fixed?
46:47
Well, I think there's, there's, there's compli-- I think when it comes to the healthcare funding, there's complexities 'cause obviously there's state funding and there's federal funding and some of the, uh, some of the fixes need to be, uh, money from the feds.
46:56
So looking at, you know, improvements in community care and getting people, you know, out of hospitals into aged care facilities.
47:01
But clearly there's a capacity issue within the hospitals to be able to manage those, as those elective surgical lists and, and, uh, improve capacity or improve the bed numbers within the hospital system, uh, to be able to, um, get patients out of ED and off ambulance trolleys.
47:15
So, Doctor, that sounds like maybe a bit of pass the parcel goes on with regard to just fixing problems.
47:20
I think the solutions are, you know, they're multi-level solutions.
47:23
Um, but, um, certainly, um, you know, we see the, uh, y- you-- as I said, the access into community care, GP care as part of this big, um, big complex puzzle.
47:33
Uh, but certainly it comes down to, uh, who pays and where the money comes from.
123:28
Simon, do you really have to do this?
123:31
We don't want to do this, I think is the point.
123:33
We would much rather the government actually sit down with us and negotiate a settlement to our enterprise bargaining agreement.
123:40
That's been a process that's been going on for over a year now.
123:44
We're on to our third health minister.
123:46
We've probably had 70 to 80 meetings in that time with government representatives, and we still don't have... an offer on the table.
123:55
So unfortunately, we feel like we need to sort of escalate our concerns.
125:10
So you've reached agreement, but not quite.
4:52
... to be somewhat outraged by this?
4:56
Uh, yeah, look, I think everybody needs to be, um, at least at a minimum concerned and needs to ask the questions about why we're in this dire situation.
5:05
Um, I think if we look at, um, uh, any emergency department across the states, um, they've been struggling, and they've been struggling for a long time.
5:13
I know we're gonna touch on the, the rural and regional stuff a little bit later.
5:16
But, you know, as you said in your open, in your opening commentary there, the Royal Children's is one of our flagship hospitals.
5:22
It's a well-recognized hospital.
5:25
It, um, is, um, you know, delivers world-class care.
5:56
But how do you have nice, shiny, new refurbed emergency departments with beds and then not go, "Oh, actually, we don't have the money to staff them"? I, I find that absolutely incredulous.
0:14
Am I right to be somewhat outraged by this?
0:18
Yeah, look, I think everybody needs to be at least at a minimum concerned and needs to ask the questions about why we're in this dire situation.
0:27
I think if we look at any emergency department across the states, they've been struggling and they've been struggling for a long time.
0:34
I know we're going to touch on the rural and regional stuff a little bit later, but as you said in your opening commentary there, the Royal Children's is one of our flagship hospitals.
0:44
It's a well-recognized hospital that delivers world-class care but it has an emergency department that has been chronically underfunded, understaffed and we've got incredibly dedicated staff who are feeling constantly under the pump and obviously immensely disappointed about having this trouble about their staffing.
3:42
Yet our health doesn't seem to be a priority to the state government.
3:47
Yeah, I think most people would agree with that.
3:50
I think, you know, health education, it seems to be all the things that, the vital things that our communities need, health education, childcare, things that are neglected by recurrent governments.
54:06
And how much, Dr. Simon, is this also a product of the fact that cost of living, people don't want to necessarily or can afford to go to the doctor, so they go to the emergency department?
54:16
I don't think we've really looked into and really tried to calculate that specifically.
54:20
We do know that obviously we have seen issues around access to specialist care, for example, as being an issue that's been raised.
54:30
Certainly access to GPs, we would like to see the government support improved access to GPs because clearly if people can access their general practitioners and have continuity of care, It does provide a, you know, keeps people out of hospitals.
54:47
But I think the main thing that we've seen impacting EDs is the fact that our hospitals are full.
54:52
We've got, you know, many, many patients spending a long time in our hospitals, which then clogs up our emergency departments, which then leads to ambulance ramping and blows our waiting times out.
55:02
So the whole system is operating, you know, at overcapacity.
55:12
Is that the case?
38:47
What's happening that we don't have an EBA? How do we get to a situation where there's six months down the track with no contract with your employer?
38:57
I guess, you know, we probably need to ask somebody else that question because we continue to be dumbfounded by the fact that we're actually in this at this point now.
39:08
First of all, a call out to all of those doctors out there who are actually, you know, stepping up and participating in those stock work meetings.
39:20
and to the amazing staff of AMA and ASMOF for doing what they do.
39:26
It's been an incredibly long negotiation.
39:31
The definition of negotiation, it's not really negotiation because we've been trying to negotiate and we haven't really got anywhere.
39:37
And I guess the other message is none of us want to be doing this.

19 MINS LATER

59:06
What's occupying your mind at the moment about climate change?
52:14
So, Doctor, I had no idea that public hospital doctors would be unionised.
52:20
I guess it's, you know, any public service, there is a, ASMOF is a union that represents doctors and works alongside in partnership with the AMA Victoria.
52:30
But this is an action which is really focusing on safer work conditions.
52:34
We know that our public hospital doctors work in incredibly challenging environments.
52:40
The work is challenging but incredibly rewarding.
52:43
But there are a lot of work conditions that just aren't sustainable.
52:46
The long hours, not having access to You know, time off, overtime requirements, all sorts.
55:06
Have you got more than you need or less than you need?
0:44
Okay, Doctor, what has caused frustration and disappointment?
0:49
Well, we've been negotiating.
0:50
There's a cycle of enterprise bargaining agreements, and we're public hospital doctors, and so we've been working with the government for the last almost 12 months now, meetings once or twice a week for 12 months to try and negotiate changes in our work conditions.
1:08
And unfortunately, we still don't have an offer on the table.
1:11
And so...
1:12
You know, enough's enough.
1:14
You know, we need to get a resolution on this thing.
1:36
Any indications that she might be easier to deal with?
66:34
We've all made the observation in here, Doctor, that doctors don't strike us as the striking type.
66:43
Um...
66:44
No, exactly true.
66:45
And I think that's a real indicator of, I guess, the frustration and disappointment that we've, you know, bore us to this point.
66:53
It's been 20 years since we've had to take any sort of similar action.
66:58
And so, you know, we are, I guess, very disappointed that we've really got to this point.
67:04
We certainly don't want to go down this path, but we certainly, you know, we feel like we don't really have too many other options now.
67:10
Okay, Doctor, what has caused frustration and disappointment?
82:53
Look, Dr Simon, I imagine you're going to be a bit more measured in your approach, but the issue here is the same, that we've got people going to work to save lives who are being assaulted and don't have a safe workplace.
83:05
Yeah, look, I think...
83:09
I agree.
83:10
The situation has been, I think, is not just a...
83:12
I need to point out that it's not just a situation that happens in Melbourne and Victoria.
83:16
This is something that's happening across all jurisdictions across the country.
83:20
You know, we see reports out of Sydney, we receive reports out of Brisbane, we see it from the Northern Territory.
86:25
Like, this is just completely insane.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.