Skip to main content
Robert Piest

Robert Piest

Search complete. 54 mentions across 10 episodes found for "Robert Piest".

Sep 28, 2026

Elisa DonovanHOST
4:10
But John Wayne Gacy remained free.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:13
It wasn't until 15-year-old Robert Piest disappeared in 1978 that investigators finally searched Gacy's home and uncovered the horrifying truth.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:24
The respected businessman and community volunteer had murdered 33 young men and boys, burying most of them beneath and around his house.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:35
Devil in Disguise, John Wayne Gacy, tells the story not just of Gacy, but of the victims, their families, and the failures that allowed him to keep killing.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
8:13
And then I was lucky enough to, the writers I've worked with for a long time, they sort of got what the mission was and they really helped make the show what it became.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:22
Yeah, I really appreciate that so much that it's told from their perspective for the most part.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:27
And just with a generally a great respect for the The victims and it begins with Robert Peace disappearance rather than Gacy's childhood, which obviously just explained why or even the first his first murder.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:42
So why was Robert the right way into the story?
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:42
I really appreciate that so much that it's told from their perspective for the most part.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:46
And just with a generally a great respect for the the victims, and it begins with Robert Pease's disappearance rather than Gacy's childhood, which obviously you just explained why, or even his first murder.
Elisa DonovanHOST
9:01
So why was Robert the right way into the story?
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
9:05
Well, I think that part of it had to do with the fact that I had told the studio and the network that I wasn't going to show a single murder.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
10:35
And so once I, like, figured that part out, then it became, like, let's start with the last victim and then make our way back to how do we tell their stories.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
10:45
And that's part one.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
10:46
And then part two was why I start with Robert Piest was that Piest was – really the only victim that they truly took seriously, right? And so if a part of the storytelling became about how these other victims were, again, I'm being reductive for the point of this conversation right now, were ignored for various reasons, then you want to figure out why, you want to begin with why did the police pay attention? And that was Robert Peast.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
11:15
So that's why we started there.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:10
But John Wayne Gacy remained free.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:13
It wasn't until 15-year-old Robert Piest disappeared in 1978 that investigators finally searched Gacy's home and uncovered the horrifying truth.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:24
The respected businessman and community volunteer had murdered 33 young men and boys, burying most of them beneath and around his house.
Elisa DonovanHOST
4:34
Devil in Disguise, John Wayne Gacy, tells the story not just of Gacy, but of the victims, their families, and the failures that allowed him to keep killing.
Patrick MacmanusGUEST
8:12
And then I was lucky enough to, the writers I've worked with for a long time, they sort of got what the mission was and they really helped make the show what it became.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:21
Yeah, I really appreciate that so much that it's told from their perspective for the most part.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:27
And just with a generally a great respect for the The victims and it begins with Robert Peace disappearance rather than Gacy's childhood, which obviously just explained why or even the first his first murder.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:41
So why was Robert the right way into the story?
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:40
Yeah, I really appreciate that so much that it's told from their perspective for the most part.
Elisa DonovanHOST
8:45
And just with a generally a great respect for the And it begins with Robert Pease's disappearance rather than Gacy's childhood, which obviously you just explained why, or even his first murder.
Elisa DonovanHOST
9:00
So why was Robert the right way into the story?
Patrick MacManusGUEST
9:03
Well, I think that part of it had to do with the fact that I had told the studio and the network that I wasn't going to show a single murderer.
Patrick MacManusGUEST
10:34
And so once I figured that part out, then it became like, let's start with the last victim and then make our way back to how do we tell their stories.
Patrick MacManusGUEST
10:43
And that's part one.
Patrick MacManusGUEST
10:45
And then part two was why I start with Robert Piest was that Piest was... really the only victim that they truly took seriously, right? And so if a part of the storytelling became about how these other victims were, again, I'm being reductive for the point of this conversation right now, were ignored for various reasons, then you want to figure out why, you want to begin with why did the police pay attention? And that was Robert Peast.
Patrick MacManusGUEST
11:14
So that's why we started there.
speaker_13ADVERTISER
11:04
Terms and conditions apply.
Trevor McDonaldHOST
11:07
Six years later, in December 1978, 10 miles from Gacy's house, 15-year-old Des Plaines resident Rob Piest was reported missing by his mother.
Trevor McDonaldHOST
11:19
Detectives Mike Albrecht and Dave Hackmeister began to investigate the teen's disappearance.
speaker_7SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
11:26
Rob Piest was like a stellar kid.
speaker_7SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
11:29
I mean, he was the kind of kid that anyone would want as a son.
speaker_7SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
11:33
Never been in trouble, never had any inclination to run away.
Tony AntonucciSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
13:18
Sometimes at three o'clock in the afternoon, you know, John would say, hey, it's a nice day out.
Tony AntonucciSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
13:23
Let's knock off early and, you know, have some fun or do something and all normal stuff, you know, just kind of like you didn't expect, you know, your boss to, you know, be the one that wanted to knock off early.
Oren FelixHOST
56:53
Yeah.
Oren FelixHOST
56:53
Like what the fuck are we doing here? But anyway, Gacy's last known victim was a 15-year-old boy named Robert Piest.
Oren FelixHOST
57:01
And I have a picture of him if you want to pull that up.
Shayn JonesHOST
57:06
Bringing it up right now.
Oren FelixHOST
57:09
Yep.
Oren FelixHOST
57:09
There you go.
Oren FelixHOST
57:10
So this is Robert Piest, his last known victim.
Oren FelixHOST
57:14
And Gacy came into contact with Piest on December 11th of 1978.
Corinna HarrodHOST
13:46
To almost everyone who crossed his path, he looked like exactly the kind of man a town like this was supposed to produce.
Corinna HarrodHOST
13:55
Robert Piest never came home.
Corinna HarrodHOST
13:58
Elizabeth Piest reported her son missing that same evening, which was, for the era, unusually fast.
Corinna HarrodHOST
14:05
Police departments in the late 1970s often didn't treat a missing teenager as urgent for the first day or two on the assumption that the kid had probably just wandered off.
Corinna HarrodHOST
15:48
A stash of handcuffs, pornographic and stag films, capsules of amyl nitrate, a dildo, a 2x4 with two holes drilled into each end, bottles of Valium and Atropine, several driver's licenses, a blue hooded parka and underwear too small to fit Gacy.
Corinna HarrodHOST
16:11
They also found a Nissan Pharmacy photo receipt in the rubbish alongside a 36-inch section of nylon rope.
Corinna HarrodHOST
16:21
The pharmacy was the same as where Robert Piest worked.
Corinna HarrodHOST
16:26
They also found something else, a foul, persistent smell coming from somewhere in the house, one that neighbours had actually been complaining about for years, and this time investigators weren't willing to accept a dead rat as the final answer.
Katie RingHOST
1:52
Every Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday, I'll take you deep into cases that have a lasting imprint on society and still haunt us today.
Katie RingHOST
1:58
Last episode, 15-year-old Robert Piest vanished after leaving his job to meet a contractor about work.
Katie RingHOST
2:04
His family refused to let anyone call him a runaway.
Katie RingHOST
2:08
And when detectives started asking who Robert had left work to meet, one name kept coming up, John Wayne Gacy.
Katie RingHOST
3:29
Sell your car today on Carvana.
Katie RingHOST
3:31
Pick-up fees may apply.
Katie RingHOST
3:35
Robert Piest vanished on the night of December 11th, 1978.
Katie RingHOST
3:39
That same evening, his family filed a missing persons report, and it landed on the desk of a Des Plaines police lieutenant named Joseph Kozenczak.
speaker_3SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
19:46
no motive to run off.
speaker_3SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
19:48
Robert Piest is unusual.
speaker_3SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
19:49
He's different than the other missing young men.
speaker_3SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
19:51
He's an outlier in the sense that he's the kind of guy who's connected to his family.
Elizabeth PiestSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
21:15
and turned the corner, and he never came back.
speaker_1NARRATOR
21:18
Lieutenant Joe Kozenczak is the chief of detectives at Des Plaines PD, and this case hits especially close to home.
speaker_1NARRATOR
21:26
Kozenczak also has a teenage son, and he attends the same high school as Robert Piest.
speaker_1NARRATOR
21:33
It's not hard for him to imagine what Mrs. Piest is going through.
Katie RingHOST
21:11
A survivor had handed the police the man's name and his license plate, but it wasn't enough for them to care.
Katie RingHOST
21:17
It took a 15-year-old boy named Robert Piest to finally get anyone to care.
Katie RingHOST
21:23
Robert was a high school sophomore, an honor roll student, and a gymnast.
Katie RingHOST
21:27
He was quiet, well-liked, and very close with his family, and never got in trouble.
Katie RingHOST
23:37
They interviewed the pharmacy owner and asked him about the contractor who had been in the store that evening, and they filed a missing persons report that night.
Katie RingHOST
23:46
And the family never let up, constantly putting pressure on the police to find their son.
Katie RingHOST
23:51
Luckily, this time detectives believed the family and started actually investigating, and when they started asking who had last spoken to Robert Piest that night, one name kept coming back: John Wayne Gacy.
Katie RingHOST
24:05
This time, the police were not going to write it off.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.