Skip to main content
Precedent

Precedent

Search complete. 3 mentions across 1 episode found for "Precedent".

Aug 20, 2026

Chris ScaliaGUEST
37:31
If you had invited somebody else to do it, they may have been less persnickety about it, but I [laughs] felt like I had to be a little bit more protective there.
Chris ScaliaGUEST
37:39
And then there was a line about, uh, stare decisis that made him sound more like Justice Thomas than, than himself.
Sarah IsgurHOST
37:47
Mm-hmm.
Sarah IsgurHOST
37:48
Yeah.
Chris ScaliaGUEST
37:48
Uh, so I, I thought we should, we should have changed that.
Sarah IsgurHOST
37:51
And just to explain that one for a second, 'cause I found that super interesting.
Sarah IsgurHOST
37:57
Justice Thomas's position is, especially when it comes to the Constitution, stare decisis is at its weakest, because only judges can really change constitutional interpretation, and therefore, if a previous court got it wrong about the Constitution, who cares if it's precedent? You should change it and get the Constitution right.
Sarah IsgurHOST
38:17
This is exactly why Justice Scalia used the term faint-hearted originalist.

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.