Paul Michael Stephani

[phone beeping]

From this point forward, they referred to this caller as the Weepy-Voiced Killer.

And even though they had his voice recorded, they didn't have any physical evidence, 'cause he didn't leave any at the scene with Compton either, so they didn't have much to go on.

The police would go to the diner, and they would talk to the staff that was there, and they would give a general description of the Weepy-Voiced Killer, but it wasn't enough to pinpoint a suspect, so once again, this case went cold too.

Six months later, the police receive yet another call.

Please don't talk.

The night before, Barbara had been out at a bar, and she'd offered a cigarette to a man she hadn't met before.

They began flirting and kinda hit it off, and at one point they were gonna leave together, and before they left, Barbara turns to one of the waitresses and kinda jokingly says, "Boy, I hope he's nice, 'cause I'm leaving with him." And the waitress, for whatever reason, had a really bad feeling about it and made a point of getting a really good look at the man she was leaving with.

...

the only time it ever made its way into a Morbid episode was the Weepy-Voiced Killer, and it was because of him.

Yeah, just because of h- the voice.

Other than that, I, both of us are not-