Skip to main content
Nicholas Lemann

Nicholas Lemann

American writer and academic

Sep 1, 2026

5:46
Middle class, the son of a small business owner, and as he looks over the student body from his wire-rimmed glasses, he doesn't like what he sees.
5:54
He had this very strong feeling that the wrong kind of people were going to Harvard and that that had to change.
6:04
America's elite universities, particularly the private ones, were completely dominated by preppies.
6:11
White Anglo-Saxon Protestant tended to be from the big cities, especially of the East Coast, and they were sort of culturally dominant in these schools.
6:20
He was very worried about this sort of preppy aristocracy that wasn't very competent running America.
6:28
He thought the urgent situation of the Depression, um, demanded a, a sort of better class of leaders, and he thought this was a real sort of crisis.

9 MINS LATER

15:37
It's a huge feat, and it's at this point that the College Board sees the full potential of the test.
15:43
The College Board dropped its own essay-based college boards and said, "Well, now we're just gonna use the SAT." And that's how the SAT goes from, you know, 10,000 or something administrations before the war, to over a million administrations in the '50s.
2:56
I mean, is America the place where Judaism goes to die? I
3:00
don't think so, and I hope not.
3:02
Let me try to sort of put it in a different context.
3:05
So, you know, we're at year 5800-something or 5700-something on the Jewish calendar.
3:12
So Jewish history is long.
3:15
The history of Jews believing it would even be possible or desirable to live as regular citizens in the outside world is very, very short in the larger context.
3:27
So we should keep in mind, through most of Jewish history, for better, for worse, with a lot of better and a lot of worse, Jews lived as a completely separate tribe, self-governing, speaking a different language, wearing different clothing, following different rules, et cetera.

25 MINS LATER

28:16
But it seems like almost every criteria that's used to evaluate students is going to correlate with socioeconomic status.
9:30
They were players that plant themselves in Louisiana and stick in Louisiana.
9:34
Yeah.
9:34
So I don't think they...
9:36
I, I think the plan was we'll just move to New York and join the sort of German Jewish world in New York, um, and all of the things you just said would happen.
9:46
But...
9:47
And they would be kind of, um, running the business in Louisiana from afar and maybe transitioning out.
9:55
Uh, but then the Civil War came along.

35 MINS LATER

44:33
Can you talk a little about that?
17:54
Yeah.
17:54
In my family, there was a mythology that, you know, this was our story, a very weird Jewish story.
18:01
The quick way to say it is we were Jewish plantation owners.
18:05
Although, as one of my friends said, "Oh, Shimon Legree." [laughs] Um, so our family acquired plantations after emancipation because they had roots in this sugar planting town in rural Louisiana and saw a business opportunity.
18:25
So the family preferred mythology was we only became involved in plantation owning after emancipation.
18:34
Now-That itself is somewhat problematic because, you know, this is an overwhelming white supremacy atmosphere, but we weren't literally plantation slaveholders.
18:47
So I went to the parish, you know, we have parishes instead of counties in Louisiana, the parish courthouse, and there's a guy there who knows everything and is the master of this very elaborate set of records going way, way back, many of which are handwritten, many of which are written in French.
19:18
Hmm
1:18
Let's start with, uh, talk to me a little bit about the early research in this, and then kind of like take me through the history of how you guys got into this and, um, how it started.
1:36
All right.
1:36
You, uh, I think you already introduced it, uh, quite well since, uh, the study you've been talking about where we document that trauma-specific reflective functioning was, uh, important for mother-child attachment was the very first study on, uh, that concept of, uh, trauma-specific mentalizing.
1:56
So that's, uh, a work I've been doing, uh, at, uh, Université Laval in Quebec, Canada, with, uh, Professor Carolyn Cinqué in the course of my, uh, PhD dissertation, where we, uh, were working with a quite large sample of, uh, pregnant women who have experienced childhood maltreatment or childhood abuse or, or neglect.
2:18
We were looking at their adaptation to, uh, motherhood, uh, were they doing, um, how the relationship with their infant eventually unfold.
2:29
And we had access in the course of that research to a narrative about their experiences with their attachment figures, so generally their, their two parents.
2:40
And we were coding attachment and reflective functioning.
6:39
You have this two twenty-- two thousand twenty-five article called "Characterizing the Heterogeneity of Disruptions in the Resolution of Trauma Among Women Exposed to Childhood Maltreatment." You wanna describe this study maybe, uh, in general, and then we can get into the specifics on the different types of profiles that came through in the trauma narratives.
10:40
Mm-hmm
10:40
...
10:40
the big issue in the South is always race, Jews on average are more liberal on race.
10:48
Um, but, uh, I guess for that reason, in my family...
10:54
Let me give you a little bit of the history to, to work my way up to it.
10:58
So this, these were things I didn't really know before I did research for the book.
11:03
Um, great-grand- great-great-grandfather settled in New Orleans, I mean, in, in Donaldsonville.

23 MINS LATER

33:59
Mm-hmm
72:55
Uh, was that all new to you?
72:56
you?No, that was new to me because, um, you know...
73:02
So just to sketch it out, my grandfather, um, was lucky enough to have been a classmate at Harvard Law School, class of 1906, with Felix Frankfurter, the future Supreme Court justice, and they were intimate friends for half a century and more after that, living in different cities, so they have this huge correspondence going back and forth.
73:26
So if listeners don't know, um, FDR was very frustrated when he was president that the conservative Supreme Court kept batting down his legislation and declaring it unconstitutional.
73:39
So he said, "Look, the Constitution doesn't specify how many members the Court should have, so let's just expand it.
73:46
I just want a landslide victory.
73:48
I'll throw three or four more justices on there, and then w- I won't keep having my laws s- slap down." So this was the plan that he proposed.

14 MINS LATER

87:32
... uh, books at the Harvard Business School tell us that.
15:55
So I wonder how you connected, or did you connect at all, those experiences of antisemitism and race, or how you made sense of that as a kid.
16:05
It's the same story where many things about my childhood just, people I know now on the Upper West Side just, it mystifies them.
16:16
Um, but it's just what everybody thought when I was a kid.
16:19
So I grew up in a world where my school was, uh, by charter for whites only.
16:27
That didn't change until I had almost graduated from high school, and it only changed because the federal government said it would take away the tax deduction of nonprofit institutions if they were white only.
16:41
So that was just assumed.
16:43
Everybody I knew lived in an intensely racialized world that was a caste system.

12 MINS LATER

28:53
I'm wondering how you square all of that.
2:32
Can you tell us a little bit about the family background that you explored? When did your ancestors arrive in New Orleans and why, by the time that you came around, do you think that your family was so assimilated? And in what ways were they really part of this larger, more Catholic culture in New Orleans? And in what ways were they always just going to stand out?
2:52
We were part of a very distinct subculture that has an interesting history and it no longer exists.
3:01
So it's a little bit like describing a vanished civilization, but I'll just describe it.
3:08
So I'm talking about using Temple Sinai as a sort of shorthand for the community.
3:15
So in the early 19th century, there was a migration of Jews from basically either side of the Rhine River in Germany and Alsace to America.
3:30
It wasn't like a mass migration, but it was different from the picture you have of the heyday of Ellis Island, including that people didn't go to Ellis Island.
3:41
And Ellis Island hadn't been built yet.
5:33
You know, in what ways was your family, you know, by the time that you came around, blending with this larger, more Catholic community that exists in Louisiana? And in what ways were they kind of always standing out? And also, why? Why did they want to assimilate?
47:18
What are the lessons about desiring to assimilate that seem sometimes, uh, lead to great tragedies, especially in Germany in the 1930s? What do those lessons about the desire to assimilate, uh, have for today when there's been a rise of anti-Semitism both in Europe and the United States?
47:38
So there was this long-running process in Germany of what's called German- Jewish emancipation, which was not completed until 1871.
47:47
That was when Jews became completely, you know, full citizens with full rights of the German nation.
47:55
And then by 10 years later, there was a very active anti-Semitic movement in Germany that sort of built and built and built until you got the Nazis.
48:05
So in America today, you know, you have a half, roughly, of the Jews in the world, there aren't that many, living in Israel, and you have a tremendous amount of anti-Israel sentiment both on the left and the right.
48:21
And so, you know, most American Jews were raised to think that, you know, Israel is our homeland, and even if we don't live there, it's part of our identity.
48:32
But especially if you're younger, you really get challenged on that a-and kind of asked, uh, are you a Zionist? Um, and, and so people like my kids really struggle with that.
49:33
What in your research and in your book helped inform you, uh, for that work on anti-Semitism?

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.