Naskh
6
MENTIONS
4
EPISODES
3
PODCASTS
Search complete. 6 mentions across 4 episodes found for "Naskh".
Oct 16, 2026
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
Sorry? If now, for example, you can't make jam, and it's impossible to make jam between the two, then you see if one abrogates the other.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
A, uh, naskh.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
In order to know naskh, you have-- there has to be something which indicates, um, a date.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
So this happens before this one.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
If they don't have that, then you have tarjih.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
No? That's a, that's a third thing we do.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
So, so when you look at the sources and we look at the difference, the first thing you do, you took the-- you have the two texts, you try to make jam between the two.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
If you're not able to make jam between the two, then you look at naskh.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
He mentions, "Kunttu nahitukum min ziyarat al-quboor ala fa zurooha." And so the Nabi ﷺ, he mentions that, "I used to prohibit you from visiting the graves." Alas, ya'ani now you can ver-- you can go and visit them.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
And so this hadith, first and foremost, is an indication of what we refer to as the nasikh wal mansukh within one narration.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
The, the, the abrogated and the, and the abrogator in terms of the narration or in terms of the hukm.
Abdul Hakeem MitchellGUEST
So the ruling before was that the, it was prohibited from visiting the graves.
Shadee ElmasryHOST
How did Sayyidina Ali separate the common man from the scholar? Not by memorization.
Shadee ElmasryHOST
Sayyidina Ali bin Abi Talib would proceed to ask him about a certain verse and ask him, is it nasikh or mansukh? So why does Allah have rulings in the Quran that later on in other verses of the Quran are nullified? If you look at the verses of Ramadan, it speaks as if Ramadan is optional.
Shadee ElmasryHOST
You can fast or you can feed the poor.
Shadee ElmasryHOST
It's confusing because the next verse sometime later says you have to fast.
Mark TapsonHOST
Mm-hmm.
Aynaz Anni CyrusGUEST
Abrogation can, for example, as I said, abrogate what the Christians and Jews were considered in the Quran.
Aynaz Anni CyrusGUEST
Later verses says they're non-believers, so earlier verses considering them people of the book can be removed from the table of legal sides of Islam.
Mark TapsonHOST
Islam.Uh, you've got a great quote from the book along these lines.