Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart
86
MENTIONS
9
EPISODES
5
PODCASTS
Search complete. 86 mentions across 9 episodes found for "Murder of Cassie Jo Stoddart".
Oct 21, 2026
Pat RogersHOST
My name is Pat Rogers, and that's Connor McCarthy.
Pat RogersHOST
On our last episode, Brian Draper had just led police to a shocking videotape that he and Torey Adamcik had made.
Pat RogersHOST
We're going to go deep into that tape on this episode and much more.
Pat RogersHOST
But I think it would be a good idea to just to go back and reset and show the beginning of this tape, uh, a clip that Brian had made, um, on September 22nd inside Pocatello High School.
Connor McCarthyHOST
She just shrugs and half smiles, moving on with her day.
Connor McCarthyHOST
Imagine detectives all in a single room watching this for the first time, seeing Cassie living, breathing, alive, going to school, at her locker, changing out books.
Connor McCarthyHOST
Brian Draper spins around, almost taunting her.
Pat RogersHOST
Yeah.
speaker_1ADVERTISER
See full terms at mintmobile.com.
Pat RogersHOST
In the midst of police investigating the brutal murder of Cassie Stoddard, they come across a videotape found buried along with the knives and masks Tory Adamczyk and Brian Draper used in Cassie's murder.
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Hello, Cassie.
Pat RogersHOST
The teen killers tried to destroy the tape, and police are about to find out why.
Connor McCarthyHOST
This is episode three of The Scream Murder, a true teen horror story podcast.
Pat RogersHOST
My name is Pat Rogers and that's Connor McCarthy.
Pat RogersHOST
On our last episode, Brian Draper had just led police to a shocking videotape that he and Tori Adamczyk had made.
Pat RogersHOST
We're going to go deep into that tape on this episode and much more.
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Goodbye.
Justin DrownHOST
On the Saturday after the boys were arrested, about 500 people filled St. Anthony's in Pocatello for Cassie Jo Stoddart's funeral.
Justin DrownHOST
The first yellow was coming into the cottonwoods along the portniff.
Justin DrownHOST
Her casket was draped in white silk.
18 MINS LATER
Justin DrownHOST
Adamczyk read a prepared statement, sobbing and at times inaudible.
Justin DrownHOST
He said he was willing to accept the consequences of what he had done.
Justin DrownHOST
Anna Stoddart said she was glad they could never be out in society again.
Justin DrownHOST
They would kill if they ever got out, she said, and they had kept a list.
John GanskeSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Time is 9:15, September 22nd, 2006.
Pat RogersHOST
So when we left the last episode, Brian Draper had admitted that he had been lying about what he and Torey Adamcik had done once they left the house where Cassie was murdered.
Pat RogersHOST
He had said that he and Torey went to a movie, but now he says that's not true, and he has a new story about what happened that night.
John GanskeSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
And, and I'm here to tell you, you didn't go to the movie.
Conor McCarthyHOST
"All right, you got me.
Conor McCarthyHOST
We didn't go to the movies.
Conor McCarthyHOST
We were doing something else." What I'm about to play is the police interview with Brian Draper and his second story he's gonna tell them.
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Hold, pause there, okay?
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
The time is 9:50, September 22nd, 2006.
Pat RogersHOST
So when we left the last episode, Brian Draper had admitted that he had been lying about what he and Torey Adamcik had done once they left the house where Cassie was murdered.
Pat RogersHOST
He had said that he and Torey went to a movie, but now he says that's not true, and he has a new story about what happened that night.
Pat RogersHOST
And, and I'm here to tell you, you didn't go to the movie.
Pat RogersHOST
You got me.
Pat RogersHOST
We didn't go to the movies.
Pat RogersHOST
We were doing something else." What I'm about to play is the police interview with Brian Draper and his second story he's gonna tell them.
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Hold on one second, okay?
Justin DrownHOST
At about half past 6:00 or 7:00 that evening, at Matt and Cassie's invitation, two classmates came over.
Justin DrownHOST
Brian Draper and Toria Demchick were 16 as well, juniors at Pocatello High, and she knew them.
Justin DrownHOST
She let them into the house she was responsible for.
Justin DrownHOST
Then she walked them through it room by room.
19 MINS LATER
speaker_4SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Okay? Now, you're saying, you're saying that he has knowledge of that you're gonna go through cars.
Brian DraperSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Yes.
speaker_4SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Detectives spoke to Brian Draper and Torey Adamcik on the Sunday evening within hours after the body had been found.
speaker_4SOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
Beckham had told them who else had been in that house.
Connor McCarthyHOST
Today, I'm here to share the first episode of a brand-new podcast from ABC News Studios and Lone Wolf Media, The Scream Murder: A True Teen Horror Story.
Connor McCarthyHOST
This six-part series will unravel the shocking story behind the brutal murder of Cassie Stoddart, a 16-year-old from Idaho.
Connor McCarthyHOST
It's an unprecedented deep dive into a story of how teenage insecurity and the love of horror movies twisted into something terrible.
Connor McCarthyHOST
Today, you'll hear the first episode, but stick around.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
Like, he thinks that would be a big thrill.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
So he teams up with his best friend, this guy, Torey.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
And Torey is also 16, and he also loves scary movies.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
And at some point in 2006, these two get together and they start talking about wanting to murder people.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
Like a lot of people.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
Like they don't even think murdering people should be illegal, that's how into it they are.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
And so they make a death list of people they wanna take out, like people at school and even some of their own friends are on the list.
Ray William JohnsonHOST
Then they start planning their first murder and how they're gonna be able to pull it off without getting caught.
Michael OjibwayHOST
So for this purpose, they requested transporting two other convicted murderers into the courtroom Yeah, you heard that right.
Michael OjibwayHOST
They attempted to have convicted killers Tori Adamczyk and Brian Draper present and testify during the trial.
Michael OjibwayHOST
These two young men from Pocatello were responsible for the murder of their classmate, Cassie Jo Stoddart, in 2006.
Michael OjibwayHOST
The case had some similarities to Norrie's murder, including a stabbing during a home invasion in the same city and a similar time period, but that was all, just some overlapping details.