Skip to main content
Joseph J. Ellis

Joseph J. Ellis

American historian

Aug 30, 2026

25:18
in
25:18
America.
25:20
He's an immigrant and comes to America as a young boy and at a very early age, involved in a mercantile house in Philadelphia and establishes a company, which is the major trading company in Japan and in the Caribbean, as well as North America and the Mediterranean region.
25:38
And during the war, he uses his credit to promote trade with France that's illegal trade.
25:49
Morris's credit was worth more than American credit.
25:53
I mean, and if Morris promised you that he was going to pay you back, you knew that you would get it.
25:57
If America does, you knew you're never going to get it.

11 MINS LATER

36:53
Why? What slowed it down, Professor?
4:13
What did that give him in power over the American cause?
4:20
It meant that he had 800,000 pounds, I believe it is, to spend based on the royal treasury to essentially And so while George III, in moving towards a policy of war with America, claimed that he was doing it to defend Parliament's authority.
4:51
In fact, Parliament was under his control.
4:55
And so it was really a monarchical act.
5:00
In the Goyas Revolution, the English government became what they said, king in Parliament.
5:07
Parliament was the most powerful.
5:09
The king was symbolic.

6 MINS LATER

11:37
Professor, what was John Dickinson in 74-75 to the cause?
3:26
Sure
3:26
... hold two ideas in your mind simultaneously and still function.
3:31
One of the things I wanna let your viewers hear is that the United States faced a unique dilemma in 1776.
3:39
Not, not only in went into war against Great Britain, but also that if you owned slaves in Brit- in anywhere in England, in Great Britain, in France, and you were forced to free them, where were they? They were an ocean away in the Caribbean and Latin America.
3:57
If you free them here, they're your neighbors, and they're 20% of the total population.
4:04
And so the issue at stake isn't just, should we end slavery? The issue is, should we become a biracial society? And the answer to that in both Northern and Southern states, and we'll talk about that, is no.
4:19
No nation in the world had ever done that, by the way.

26 MINS LATER

29:59
You know, uh, in all these episodes I've done, Joseph, about the Semi-Quincentennial, I tend to take a positive historical view of the American Revolution, but I don't think any Native American tribe could see that as a positive development in history.
Lewis LaphamSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
12:29
So the British Navy under Admiral Richard Howe and the British Army under his brother Howe William, I think, is in Brooklyn, right? I mean, and at the same time that the declaration is being written in Philadelphia.
12:54
George Washington brings the Continental Army, it's only about 10,000 troops, down from Boston to New York to defend New York because they know that's where the British are going to invade.
13:05
and presumably then move up to Hudson and sever New England off from the rest of the colonies.
13:10
That's the plan, the British strategy.
13:14
In retrospect, which means hindsight wisdom of the historian, it was a huge mistake to try to defend New York because it's an archipelago surrounded by water and whoever controls the sea controls the battle.
13:31
But Washington believed he had no choice but to do so because he was ordered by the Continental Congress to do so.
13:39
And also it catches a shred of his personality here that Washington began the war believing that battle was like a challenge to duel.

5 MINS LATER

Lewis LaphamSOUNDBITE_SPEAKER
19:08
Right.
25:00
I know he didn't want to at first.
25:03
You're raising a very important point, and it needs to note of it, throughout the American Revolution, the war, the Continental Army was kept on life support.
25:13
People were willing to give money or to volunteer for militia for local war, but not to the Continental Army.
25:22
So throughout the war, Washington is aware of the fact.
25:24
Washington said, "If you give me what we could get out of this population, we could have an army of 60 to 80,000." He never had an army more than 12,000, or 12 to 15,000.
25:36
He said he could have won the war, and Hamilton agreed with him, in two years if the, if the population had supported the Continental Army.
25:44
So he is a nationalist.
30:37
... talk about what Washington handled?
24:47
and that the band already too weak which holds us together will soon be broken it just really struck me that that thinking that he was going through and i and i'm wondering just why you think he was willing to come back i know he didn't want to at first
25:03
You're raising a very important point, and it needs to be noted.
25:07
Throughout the American Revolution, the war, the Continental Army was kept on life support.
25:13
People were willing to give money or to volunteer for militia for local war, but not to the Continental Army.
25:22
So throughout the war, Washington is aware of the fact, Washington said, if you give me what we could get out of this population, we could have an army of 60 to 80,000.
25:32
He never had an army more than 12,000 or 12 to 15,000.
25:36
He said he could have won the war.
30:35
his slaves, right? So can you talk about how Washington handled it?
26:57
But they worked pretty well together that summer in Philadelphia, didn't they?
27:01
Oh, yeah.
27:02
Um, Adams was the guy who'd led the way in the Congress on the debate towards independence.
27:09
He had embraced that position, and he said all those who were waiting, uh, were waiting for a Messiah that would never come.
27:17
So he was...
27:18
And i- in the play, 1776, they do a good job with this, showing him, um, that, uh, Jefferson was pretty close in terms of coming along on the, uh, question of independence.
27:32
And, um, and when the committee was created to draft a do- And there's a, there's a, a portrait.

12 MINS LATER

39:16
Mm-hmm.
1:52
John Adams, on the other hand...
1:54
Adams went to his grave thinking Jefferson got too much credit.
1:58
The, the whole question of independence had been decided by that time.
2:02
The American people actually deserved it because he, Adams, in May, required the Congress to send every state an order to redo their constitutions, which they did, and to answer the question, "Do you or do you not commit to American independence?" They all said yes.
2:24
And Adams said that was where the lightning struck, and Jefferson's declaration was just a thunderous aftermath.
2:32
And, um, so it gets complicated, but it's fun to keep trying to understand these people.

17 MINS LATER

20:02
Here's Joseph Ellis.
20:05
After the declaration was published, and it was, the date is July 4th, was written atop it, the Congress decided to send it to Washington, who had an army of about 25,000 in New York, who were waiting.
2:58
So what is the opinion of the Confederation Congress, 'eighty-three to 'eighty-five, towards the Native Americans, professor?
3:06
The, the official position of the Congress, and later on Washington will say he doesn't agree with all this, but that at that time, that the Native Americans w-- are a conquered people, that they, the Iroquois sided with the British.
3:21
Of course, many other tribes didn't, but that they, they had no rights whatso- at all.
3:26
Um, it's a very Eurocentric view of, of, of, of the situation.
3:30
And so that, uh, you can begin to see Indian removal taking hold, even though officially it doesn't happen until eighteen thirty under Jackson.
3:41
The origins and the, the rationale for it is present right at the end of the war.
3:45
It's quite clear, um, that, um, the...
7:20
Why? What, what slowed it down, Professor?
7:02
Who is Robert Morris and what is his part?
7:05
Robert Morris is called the financier of the American Revolution.
7:08
He's probably the wealthiest man in Philadelphia, and maybe the wealthiest man in, uh, America.
7:14
Uh, he, he's an immigrant, uh, and, uh, comes to America as a young boy, and at a very early age, involved in a mercantile house in Philadelphia and establishes a company which is the major trading company in Japan-- in, uh, in, in the Caribbean as well as North America and the Mediterranean.
7:34
And during the war, he uses his, his credit to promote, uh, trade with Europe, with France, that's illegal trade.
7:44
Uh, Morris's credit was worth more than American credit.
7:48
Uh, I mean, and if Morris promised you that he was gonna pay you back, you knew that you would get it.
10:06
Who did he complain to? Who listened to him in Congress? Anyone?
4:27
Professor, was that an order to f- York-- uh, to, uh, Cornwallis? Uh, was that his thinking that the fleet will arrive and rescue me? Why did he put himself in that trap?
4:39
He was ordered to by General Clinton, his superior, back in New York, uh, uh, because Clinton believed that the French and American army was gonna attack New York, where he was, and he was gonna need Cor- a portion of Cornwallis' troops.
4:54
So he wanted them to be on Yorktown Peninsula, so they could easily move up.
4:59
He doesn't realize, does Clinton, until it's too late, that the Continental Army is going around New York and going all the way down to Yorktown.
5:07
And, um, it's uncharacteristic of Cornwallis' behavior.
5:11
Cornwallis was an aggressive person.
5:12
He didn't like to fight in the defensive, and he really didn't get along with Clinton at all and had disobeyed his orders on many occasions.
6:54
Is that correct, Professor? Even after Yorktown, he thinks the war goes on.
2:15
Was there any thought now that it's time to get out, or were they too bloody-minded already?
2:23
There were thoughts in certain members of the House of Commons and a few in the House of Lords, but at the very top, the two people that remained committed to, uh, try to win the, the war against the Americans are George III and George Germain.
2:39
Everybody else is willing to cut its losses here, because as you have indicated, the entry of the French provide them with a... present them with a real dilemma.
2:49
How can we defend the rest of the empire? It's like the dominoes are fall-falling the other way here.
2:54
Um, if we try to win the war against the Americans, we lose the other parts of our empire.
3:00
So, uh, after that, it's difficult in retrospect to believe and to, um, to rationalize why they continued the war.
3:08
Um, but they do, um, and, uh, and it, and it, a-and in both place-- Well, in, in, in the United States, or what comes to be the United States, everybody thinks the war is essentially over, um, or it's ending, and you lose a le-- the level of commitment to the cause, um, especially at the local level now.

6 MINS LATER

9:26
What did the British promise the Iroquois Nation? What was the negotiation that they would come in on the British side?
2:06
How does Greene help him?
2:08
Greene takes over the responsibility for Quartermaster Corps.
2:13
There's nobody to do the job.
2:14
He does it, and, uh, he, he manages to send foraging patrols out further eventually to provide enough, uh, food.
2:25
This comes by the time-- not until April.
2:28
About twelve hundred American soldiers die of malnutrition or exposure during the winter of, uh, Valley Forge.
2:37
Um, so it really is the kind of, uh, you know, it's, it, it's, it's the time for the-- what I call the few.

6 MINS LATER

8:19
The, the enlisted men, who are they? Where do they come from?
2:21
Before the Howes arrive back with a fleet to dominate the story, why does George Washington believe New York is important? Why does he move his forces from Boston, where they're quite secure, to Long Island?
2:37
He moves it because he knows, and the American Congress knows, that that's the place the British are going to focus on and attack.
2:45
They know there's a British strategy to take New York, whose harbor is invaluable for the British Navy, but it will be the headquarters.
2:53
And, and then a British army coming down from Quebec will meet a British army coming up from New York in the Mohawk Valley and seal off New England.
3:04
And then the two armies together will march across New England, devastate everything.
3:08
The Navy will blow up the cities, and that's their strategy for victory.
3:12
So Washington takes his ten thousand troops, which are then supplemented by another twenty thousand militia from Pennsylvania, Mary-- uh, New York, uh, Connecticut to defend this archipelago.
7:00
Nathanael Greene and Israel Putnam, what do we need to know about them, Professor?
1:47
Professor, what was John Dickinson in seventy-four, seventy-five to the cause?
1:53
He was the single most, uh, listened to voice.
1:57
He was the most prominent figure, and he was only twenty-eight years old.
2:00
He was educated at King's College at now Columbia in New York and, and spent some time in the Middle Temple in London.
2:08
Very well-educated young man, but he's the kind of creature who would have simply never appeared in history if it weren't for this crisis.
2:16
Crises create leadership or creates opportunities for it.
2:20
And he's called-- He had a series of essays, uh, under the title The Farmer, uh, Letters from the Farmer, which lie-- which frame out the American constitutional position.
7:30
And now Tom Paine, thirty-seven years old, what is his position toward the cause? How was he regarded?
1:31
Who called what we now see the revolution the Cause, and why did they call it the Cause? Good evening to you.
1:39
Good evening to you, Robert.
1:41
Um, the Cause is what the American colonists began to use as a term to describe their opposition to British policy, um, in the late-- the mid seventeen seventies.
1:55
And, um, nobody called it the American Revolution at that time or even until at the end of the war.
2:02
Um, the British called it the American Rebellion.
2:06
And originally, the phrase was the Common Cause.
2:10
It was a term that the twelve other colonies used to describe their willingness to support Massachusetts when Massachusetts was occupied by the British Army in the wake of the Tea Party and what's called the Coercive Acts as a way of punishing that particular colony.
4:38
What did that give him i-in power over the American cause?
Judy Woodruff
Judy WoodruffCORRESPONDENT
46:51
Ellis contends a second major failure was the exclusion of Native Americans, who were not citizens, had no vote, and were not considered in the treaty that formally declared the United States a nation at the end of the Revolutionary War.
47:07
They basically c- confiscated all their property, claiming that they lost the war or something.
47:11
They didn't lose the war.
47:12
One of the things that propels me towards a more positive view of Washington is that Washington is president, and he's very busy, and, uh, his, uh, Secretary of War comes to him and says, "Unless we do something, we're on a path that the only Native Americans east of the Mississippi will be in history books.
47:32
Your f- whole future as a distinguished American president will depend upon you getting this right."
Judy Woodruff
Judy WoodruffCORRESPONDENT
47:51
Ellis said George Washington, in particular, was aware the failures in the founding documents would haunt him.
47:58
If you wanna understand this chapter in American history, the greatest generation of political leaders in American history did unbelievably large things that we're celebrating right now, and they failed.
48:10
S- and guess what? Of all of them, Washington knew it the most.
2:56
So what is the opinion of the Confederation Congress, eighty-three to eighty-five, towards the Native Americans, Professor?
3:05
The, the official position of the, of Congress, and later on, Washington will say he doesn't agree with all this, but the... at that time, that the Native Americans w- are a conquered people, that they, the Iroquois, sided with the British.
3:20
Of course, many other tribes didn't, but they, they, they have no rights whatso- at all.
3:24
Um, it's a very Eurocentric view of, of, of, the situation.
3:28
So, uh, you can begin to see Indian removal taking hold, even though officially it doesn't happen until eighteen thirty under Jackson.
3:39
The origins and the, the rationale for it is present right at the end of the war.
3:44
It's quite clear, um, that, um, the... and the, the way it's gonna play is that instead of going to war with them, we're going to simply allow the demographic wave of settlers coming, pursuing their happiness across the Alleghenies, all carrying diseases which the Native Americans have no immunity to.
7:19
Why? What, what slowed it down, Professor?
7:13
Who is Robert Morris, and what is his part?
7:17
Robert Morris is called the financier of the American Revolution.
7:20
He's the probably the wealthiest man in Philadelphia, and maybe the wealthiest man in, uh, America.
7:26
Uh, he, he's an immigrant, uh, and, uh, comes to America as a young boy and at a very early age, involved in a mercantile house in Philadelphia and establishes a company which is the major trading company in Japan...
7:41
in, uh, in, in the Caribbean, as well as North America and the Mediterranean.
7:46
And during the war, he, uh, uses his, his credit to promote, uh, trade with Europe, with France.
7:53
That's illegal trade.
10:19
Who did he complain to? Who listened to him in Congress? Anyone?
4:28
Professor, was that an order to f- Yor- uh, to, uh, Cornwallis? Uh, was that his thinking, that the fleet will arrive and rescue me? Why did he put himself in that trap?
4:40
He was ordered to by General Clinton, his superior, back in New York, uh, uh, because Clinton believed that the French and American army was gonna attack New York, where he was, and he was gonna need Cor- a portion of Cornwallis's troops.
4:56
So he wanted them to be on Yorktown Peninsula, so they could easily move up.
5:00
He doesn't realize, does Clinton, until it's too late, that the Continental Army is going around New York and going all the way down to Yorktown.
5:08
And, um, it's uncharacteristic of Cornwallis's behavior.
5:12
Cornwallis was an aggressive person.
5:14
He didn't like to fight on the defensive, and he really didn't get along with Clinton at all and had disobeyed his orders on many occasions.
6:57
Is that correct, Professor? Even after Yorktown, he thinks the war goes on.
2:45
Was there any thought now that it's time to get out, or were they too bloody-minded already?
2:52
There were thoughts in certain members of the House of Commons and a few in the House of Lords, but at the very top, the two people that remained committed to, uh, trying to win the, the war against the Americans are George III and George Germain.
3:08
Everybody else is willing to cut its losses here, 'cause as you have indicated, the entry of the French provide them with a... present them with a real dilemma: "How can we defend the rest of the empire?" It's like the dominoes are fall- falling the other way here.
3:24
Um, if we try to win the war against the Americans, we lose the other parts of our empire.
3:30
So, uh, after that, it's difficult in retrospect to believe and to, um, to rationalize why they continued the war.
3:37
Um, but they do, um, and, uh, and it, and it, a- and in both place-- well, in, in, in the United States, well, when it comes to the United States, everybody thinks the war is essentially over, um, or it's ending, and you lose a le- the level of commitment to the cause, um, especially at the local level now.
3:59
People are receding to their own towns and communities.

6 MINS LATER

9:51
What did the British promise the Iroquois Nation? What was the negotiation that they would come in on the British side?
2:50
Before the Howes arrive back with a fleet to dominate the story, why does George Washington believe New York is important? Why does he move his forces from Boston, where they're quite secure, to Long Island?
3:06
He moves it because he knows, and the American Congress knows, that that's the place the British are going to focus on and attack.
3:14
They know there's a British strategy to take New York, whose harbor is invaluable for the British Navy, but it will be the headquarters.
3:22
And, and then a British army coming down from Quebec will meet a British army coming up from New York in the Mohawk Valley and seal off New England.
3:33
And then the two armies together will march across New England, devastate everything, the navy will blow up the cities, and that's their strategy for victory.
3:41
So Washington takes his ten thousand troops, which are then supplemented by another twenty thousand militia from Pennsylvania, Maryl- uh, uh, New York, uh, Connecticut, to defend this archipelago.
3:56
Notice, New York is a set of islands, and, um, any military assessment of the terrain should have informed Washington that this was an indefensible position.
7:27
Nathanael Greene and Israel Putnam, what do we need to know about them, Professor?
1:53
How does Greene help him?
1:56
Greene takes over the responsibility for Quartermaster Corps.
2:00
There's nobody to do the job.
2:02
He does it, and, uh, he, he manages to send foraging patrols out further, eventually, to provide enough, uh, food.
2:12
Th- This comes by the time... not until April.
2:15
About twelve hundred, uh, American soldiers die of n- malnutrition or exposure during the winter of, uh, Valley Forge.
2:24
Um, so it really is a kind of, uh, you know, it's, it, it's, it's a time for the, what I call the few.

6 MINS LATER

8:11
The, the enlisted men, who are they? Where do they come from?
1:18
Professor, what was John Dickinson in seventy-four, seventy-five to the cause?
1:24
He was the single most, uh, listened to voice.
1:27
He was the most prominent figure, and he was only twenty-eight years old.
1:30
He was educated at King's College, uh, now Columbia in New York, and, and spent some time in the Middle Temple in London.
1:39
Very well-educated young man, but he's the kind of creature who would've simply never appeared in history if it weren't for this crisis.
1:46
Crises create leadership or create the opportunities for it.
1:50
And he's called...

5 MINS LATER

7:01
And now Tom Paine, thirty-seven years old, what is his position toward the cause? How is he regarded?
1:32
Who called what we now see the revolution the Cause, and why did they call it the Cause? Good evening to you.
1:40
Good evening to you, uh, Robert.
1:41
It's, um, the Cause is what the American colonists began to use as a term to describe their opposition to British policy, um, in, uh, the late...
1:54
the mid-1770s, and, um, nobody called it the American Revolution at that time or even until at the end of the war.
2:03
Um, the British called it the American Rebellion, and originally, the phrase was the Common Cause.
2:10
It was a term that the twelve other colonies used to describe their willingness to support Massachusetts when Massachusetts was occupied by the British Army in the wake of the Tea Party and what's called the Coercive Acts, as a way of punishing that particular colony.
2:29
Um, once you get to this, the summer of 'seventy-six, the Common Cause becomes simply the Cause, and I see it as a kind of verna, um, a, a canopy, uh, uh, over... a verbal canopy over a variety of interest groups.
4:39
What did that give him i- in power over the American cause?

Scroll for more appearances

We value your privacy

We use cookies to understand how you use our platform and to improve your experience. Click “Accept All” to consent, or “Decline non-essential” to opt out of non-essential cookies. Read our Privacy Policy.